From the free course English Composition I on Lykke
8.9 Portfolio: Evidence and Objectivity
By the end of this section the student can: Write about the development of your composing processes.; Write about how composing processes affect your work.; Write about your objectivity as a writer.
8.9 Portfolio: Evidence and Objectivity
A reflective portfolio turns writing experience into evidence: instead of merely claiming that your composing has improved, you show how your process developed, how that process shaped your work, and how fairly you can judge your own decisions. The central question is not simply What did I write? but What did I learn about the way I write, and what demonstrates that learning?
A useful everyday comparison is a sports replay. A player who says “I played better today” offers a conclusion. A replay can show where the player changed position, reacted sooner, or made a different decision. Reflection works similarly. It revisits the composing process and uses concrete details—drafts, revisions, feedback, research choices, and final results—to support a conclusion about growth.
In this task, composing process means the series of decisions and actions through which a writer develops a piece of work. That process can include discovering a topic, gathering information, organizing ideas, drafting, receiving responses, revising, editing, and making final choices. The task asks the writer to examine the development of that process, its effects on the work, and the writer’s own objectivity.
Reflective Task: Lessons Learned
The reflective task asks you to write about lessons learned from your composing. A lesson is more than a description of what happened. “I wrote a draft and revised it” reports an event; “I learned that revising after identifying my audience produces a clearer argument” identifies an insight about composing. The strongest reflection connects an action to a result and then explains what the result taught you.
A reflection therefore moves through three related questions:
- What did I do as a writer?
- What effect did that choice have on my work?
- What do I understand now that I did not understand before?
These questions correspond to the task’s three demands. First, the writer describes the development of composing processes: how the approach changed over time. Second, the writer explains how composing processes affect the work: how planning, drafting, research, feedback, or revision influenced clarity, organization, evidence, voice, or purpose. Third, the writer considers objectivity as a writer: whether the self-assessment is balanced, evidence-based, and willing to recognize both strengths and weaknesses.
The important choice is to write about decisions rather than simply retell the assignment. A chronological account might say, “I chose a topic, wrote an introduction, added three body paragraphs, and corrected grammar.” A reflective account asks why those decisions were made and what they produced. This change matters because a portfolio demonstrates transferable knowledge: a writer should be able to carry a useful composing practice into later work rather than remember only the details of one completed paper.
For example, consider this short reflective passage:
At first, I drafted my report in the order that ideas occurred to me. The result included useful evidence, but the paragraphs repeated the same point. After outlining the claim and arranging evidence by reason, I revised the report so that each paragraph had a distinct purpose. I learned that outlining is not just a planning step for me; it is a way to test whether my reasoning is organized before I polish sentences.
The passage makes several deliberate choices. It identifies an initial process—drafting ideas in the order they appeared—rather than labeling the writer generally as “bad” or “disorganized.” It names a visible effect of that process: repetition. It then identifies a change—outlining the claim and arranging evidence by reason—and connects that change to a result: paragraphs with distinct purposes. Finally, it states a lesson that can apply to future writing. The reflection is persuasive because the lesson grows out of specific composing decisions.
The evidence in a reflective portfolio does not have to be statistical. In writing reflection, evidence can be any concrete feature that supports an observation about composing. Useful evidence might include an early draft beside a revised passage, a changed thesis, a reorganized paragraph sequence, comments from a reader, research notes, or an explanation of why particular evidence was retained or removed. The writer’s task is to interpret these details, not merely display them.
A writer should also explain the relationship between process and product. A final paper is not separate from the choices that produced it. For instance, beginning with audience awareness may lead to a more appropriate tone; comparing sources may produce a more qualified claim; revising the order of reasons may make an argument easier to follow; and reading a draft aloud may reveal awkward transitions. The reflection should make such relationships explicit rather than expecting the reader to infer them.
Objectivity is especially important when the subject is the writer’s own work. Objectivity here means making a fair judgment by considering relevant evidence instead of allowing pride, embarrassment, preference, or a single reaction to control the assessment. Objectivity does not require pretending to have no perspective. A writer naturally has a personal relationship to the work. It requires recognizing that perspective and testing it against what the writing actually does.
A common misconception is that an objective reflection must be entirely negative or entirely detached. Neither is true. Saying “everything in my paper works” is not objective, but neither is saying “nothing works.” A balanced reflection can identify an effective choice and a limitation in the same discussion. For example, a writer might explain that concrete evidence strengthens a claim while also acknowledging that the explanation connecting the evidence to the claim remains too brief.
Consider a second short example:
I am proud that the revised introduction gives readers the context they need, but my confidence in the topic sometimes led me to treat one source as more decisive than it is. In revision, I added a limitation from another source and changed “proves” to “suggests.” The argument is now more credible because the language matches the strength of the evidence.
This passage demonstrates objectivity through precision. The writer does not discard the successful introduction merely to appear critical. Instead, the writer identifies a specific weakness—overstating the authority of one source—and makes a corresponding revision. The change from “proves” to “suggests” is significant because the wording now represents the evidence more accurately. The writer’s self-assessment is credible because it admits bias, identifies its effect, and describes a corrective action.
Objectivity also affects how a writer discusses feedback. A reflective writer need not accept every comment automatically. Instead, the writer can explain which feedback revealed a genuine problem, which suggestion was adopted, and why another suggestion was not suitable for the purpose or audience. This approach treats feedback as evidence for evaluation, not as an unquestionable verdict. The writer remains responsible for the final choices.
The task’s emphasis on lessons learned means that reflection should end with an understanding of future practice. A conclusion might identify a process the writer plans to repeat, a habit the writer plans to change, or a question the writer now knows to ask earlier. The future-facing point should arise from the evidence already discussed. It should not become a vague promise such as “I will try harder”; it should name a composing decision and the reason for making it.
A strong reflective response can therefore follow this movement:
- Identify a composing practice or decision.
- Describe how that practice developed or changed.
- Show its effect on the written work.
- Use a specific feature of the writing or revision as evidence.
- Judge the result fairly, including limitations.
- State the lesson that can guide future composing.
The finished reflection should leave the reader with more than an impression of effort. It should reveal an informed writer who can observe a process, connect choices to consequences, and evaluate the result without exaggeration. Evidence makes the reflection trustworthy; attention to objectivity makes it fair; and the lesson learned makes it useful beyond the single piece included in the portfolio.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.
Source Materials
Study English Composition I on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages