From the free course English Composition I on Lykke

6.6 Editing Focus: Subject-Verb Agreement

Key concepts: Identifying the subject and verb in a sentence · Subject-verb agreement with the singular pronoun “it” · Subject-verb agreement with the plural subject “these sentences” · Compound nouns joined by “and” · Distinguishing a subject from nouns in prepositional phrases · Agreement in sentences containing introductory or interrupting phrases

By the end of this section the student can: Identify subjects and verbs in sentences.; Distinguish between subjects and verbs that agree and those that do not.

6.6 Editing Focus: Subject-Verb Agreement

A sentence can contain several nouns but only one noun or noun phrase may control the main verb. In It may not be what is best for both films and consumers, the verb forms are not chosen by the nearby plural noun films or by the paired nouns films and consumers. The main subject is the singular pronoun it, so the sentence uses the singular form is in the clause what is best.

Subject-verb agreement is the grammatical matching of a sentence’s subject and verb in number. A singular subject takes a singular verb, and a plural subject takes a plural verb. Editing for agreement therefore begins with a structural question: Which word is the subject of this verb? It does not begin with the closest noun.

Find the main subject before choosing the verb. A nearby noun may belong to a prepositional phrase or another modifying phrase and may have no effect on the verb’s number.

Identifying the Subject and Verb in a Sentence

The subject is the person, thing, idea, or noun phrase that the sentence presents as performing an action, being in a state, or receiving a description. The verb expresses the action or state. In The store survives, store is the singular subject and survives is the verb. In The stores survive, stores is the plural subject and survive is the verb.

The difference can become less visible when a sentence contains helping verbs. In The store may survive, may is a modal helping verb, while survive is the main verb. The modal may does not change form between singular and plural subjects; the subject still matters even when the visible verb form does not clearly display agreement. Compare the sentences:

  • The store may survive.
  • The stores may survive.

The subject changes from singular to plural, but may survive remains the same. In other sentences, however, the number difference appears clearly in forms such as is/are, was/were, has/have, or does/do.

A useful editing method is to reduce a long sentence to its grammatical core. Temporarily set aside introductory material, interrupting phrases, and prepositional phrases. Then identify the subject and the verb that belong together.

Example: The quality of the films is impressive.

The core is quality is impressive. The plural noun films appears inside the prepositional phrase of the films, but films is not the subject. The sentence is about the singular quality, so is is correct.

Subject-Verb Agreement with the Singular Pronoun “It”

The pronoun it is singular. When it functions as the subject, verbs that show number must take their singular forms. The sentence It may not be what is best for both films and consumers contains more than one verb, so each verb must be considered separately.

In the first clause, it is the subject of may not be. The modal may does not change, but the subject is still singular. Within the phrase what is best, the pronoun what introduces a clause, and is is the singular form required there. The sentence therefore says what is best, not what are best.

The phrase for both films and consumers does not change this agreement. It begins with the preposition for, so films and consumers function as objects of that preposition. They identify the people or things affected by what is best; they do not serve as the subject of may be or is.

Incorrect reasoning: “Because films and consumers are plural, the sentence should use a plural verb.”

Correct reasoning: “The main subject is it, and the subject inside what is best is singular in form. The nouns after for are objects of a preposition, not subjects.”

Subject-Verb Agreement with the Plural Subject “These Sentences”

The demonstrative pronoun these is plural, and these sentences is a plural subject. A plural subject takes the plural past-tense form were. Thus, the sentence These sentences were combined with and uses were because the subject is these sentences.

The sentence may be describing an editorial change in which separate sentences were joined by the conjunction and. Regardless of the surrounding explanation, the agreement is straightforward: sentences names more than one sentence, so the verb must be plural.

Compare the singular and plural patterns:

  • This sentence was combined with another sentence.
  • These sentences were combined with and.

In the first example, this sentence is singular and takes was. In the second, these sentences is plural and takes were. The words this/these provide an especially useful clue: this points to one item, while these points to more than one.

Compound Nouns Joined by “And”

A compound subject contains two or more nouns joined together. When two nouns are joined by and and function together as the subject, they usually take a plural verb. For example, Films and consumers influence the market uses influence because films and consumers form a compound plural subject.

The presence of and, however, does not automatically make the nouns the subject. In It may not be what is best for both films and consumers, films and consumers are joined by and, but they remain objects of the preposition for. The sentence is not saying that films and consumers perform the action expressed by may be. It is evaluating what may be best for them.

This distinction becomes clear when the sentence is rearranged:

  • Films and consumers influence the market.
  • The policy may be best for films and consumers.

In the first sentence, films and consumers are the compound subject. In the second, the policy is the subject, while films and consumers are objects of for. Their plural form does not control the verb.

Distinguishing a Subject from Nouns in Prepositional Phrases

A prepositional phrase begins with a preposition such as of, for, with, in, on, or by and ends with a noun or pronoun called the object of the preposition. Prepositional phrases add information, but they frequently contain nouns that can distract writers from the actual subject.

Consider this sentence: The impact of the changes is difficult to measure. The subject is impact, not changes. The phrase of the changes tells readers what kind of impact is being discussed, but it does not control the verb. Since impact is singular, the sentence uses is.

Now compare: The effects of the change are difficult to measure. The subject is effects, which is plural, so the verb is are. The noun inside the of phrase has changed from plural changes to singular change, but that change does not determine agreement. The controlling subject changes from impact to effects.

When editing, bracket or mentally remove the prepositional phrase:

  • The impact [of the changes] is difficult to measure.
  • The effects [of the change] are difficult to measure.

The shortened cores—impact is and effects are—make the agreement visible. This technique is particularly important when the noun inside the phrase is closer to the verb than the true subject.

Agreement in Sentences Containing Introductory or Interrupting Phrases

An introductory phrase appears before the main clause, while an interrupting phrase appears within it. Both can add context, description, or emphasis without becoming the grammatical subject. Writers must separate the phrase’s meaning from the main clause’s agreement.

In the sentence For those like me, with a passion for film, the only reciprocity for the love that video stores instill is to show support, the phrase For those like me introduces the sentence. The phrase with a passion for film adds information about the people being discussed. Neither phrase determines the number of the main verb.

The main subject is the only reciprocity. The verb is is, and the subject is singular because reciprocity names one response or form of return. The phrase with a passion for film is an additional modifying phrase; it does not turn the subject into those or film, and it does not require a plural verb.

Remove the introductory and interrupting material to expose the sentence’s core:

  • Expanded: For those like me, with a passion for film, the only reciprocity for the love that video stores instill is to show support.
  • Core: The only reciprocity is to show support.

The longer version may be rhetorically useful because it identifies the speaker and adds emotional context, but the grammatical relationship remains the same. For those like me and with a passion for film modify the main statement; they do not control is.

The same method works with an interrupting phrase placed after the subject: The only reciprocity, with a passion for film guiding the speaker, is to show support. The phrase between the commas interrupts the sentence, but the subject remains reciprocity. A writer should locate the subject on one side of the interruption and connect it to the main verb on the other.

A Reliable Editing Procedure

Subject-verb agreement is easiest to check as a sequence of deliberate decisions rather than as a matter of whether a sentence “sounds right.”

  1. Locate the main verb. Identify the verb that makes the sentence’s central claim.
  2. Ask who or what the verb describes or acts upon. That noun or noun phrase is the subject.
  3. Set aside distractions. Temporarily remove prepositional phrases, introductory phrases, and interrupting phrases.
  4. Check the subject’s number. Decide whether the subject is singular or plural.
  5. Choose the matching verb form. Use is/was/has with singular subjects and are/were/have with plural subjects when those forms apply.
  6. Restore the phrases and reread the complete sentence. Confirm that the meaning remains clear.

For example, in The benefits of the proposal, with several safeguards, are substantial, remove the added phrases: The benefits are substantial. The subject benefits is plural, so are is correct. In The main benefit of the proposal, with several safeguards, is substantial, the core is benefit is substantial, so is is correct.

The most common misconception is that the noun closest to the verb controls agreement. In fact, grammatical closeness is not the same as grammatical authority. A nearby noun may be the object of a preposition, part of an interrupting phrase, or simply a modifier. Good editing follows the sentence’s structure back to its main subject before selecting the verb.

Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.

Source Materials

Study English Composition I on Lykke

This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.

Add the free extensionSign in to open every section

All sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages

6.6 Editing Focus: Subject-Verb Agreement — English Composition I | Lykke