From the free course English Composition I on Lykke
5.4 Annotated Sample Reading: “Remembering John Lewis” by Carla D. Hayden
Key concepts: Annotated sample reading · “Remembering John Lewis” · Carla D. Hayden · John Lewis’s childhood in rural Alabama · Sharecropping background · Racial segregation and discriminatory signs · Fear experienced by Black children · Parents’ and grandparents’ guidance · Harper (2020) · Ira Glass and This American Life; Mark Hartsell and the Library of Congress Blog
By the end of this section the student can: Determine and articulate how conventions are shaped by purpose, language, culture, and expectation.; Analyze and evaluate relationships between ideas and patterns of organization in the profile genre.
5.4 Annotated Sample Reading: “Remembering John Lewis” by Carla D. Hayden
A short profile can carry an entire historical movement when it chooses the right beginning. In “Remembering John Lewis,” Carla D. Hayden begins not with Lewis’s most famous public achievements but with a frightened child reading racist signs in rural Alabama. That choice gives the reader a personal entry point into the larger history of segregation, family guidance, and civil rights activism.
Learning Outcomes
A careful reading of Hayden’s profile develops two connected abilities. First, you can determine how writing conventions are shaped by purpose, language, culture, and expectation. A profile about a major civil rights leader is not simply a list of dates and accomplishments. Its language must make historical conditions understandable, its details must respect the subject and the communities involved, and its organization must help readers see how a person’s experiences connect to later actions.
Second, you can analyze the relationship between ideas and patterns of organization in the profile genre. Hayden presents a sequence of connected experiences: Lewis’s childhood, the conditions created by racial discrimination, the advice he received from his family, and his eventual inspiration to become an activist. The organization is meaningful because it shows development. Lewis’s activism does not appear as an isolated personal decision; it grows from a childhood shaped by fear, family instruction, and the racial realities of the American South.
Key insight: In a profile, organization is an argument about significance. The order in which a writer presents facts influences how readers understand the subject.
Introduction
“Remembering John Lewis” is an annotated sample reading by Carla D. Hayden. The profile remembers Lewis by connecting the public figure known for civil rights activism with the child who experienced racial discrimination directly. Hayden’s approach makes the subject human without separating him from history. Lewis appears as a person formed by place, family, culture, and political conditions.
The opening description identifies Lewis as “the son of a sharecropper” who grew up in rural Alabama. A sharecropper was a farmer who worked land owned by someone else and paid through a portion of the crops or earnings. That background matters because it places Lewis within a particular economic and geographic setting. He was not introduced as an abstract national symbol. He came from a rural family whose work and circumstances shaped his early life.
The phrase “growing up in rural Alabama” also carries historical meaning. Rural Alabama was part of the segregated American South, where laws, customs, and institutions separated Black people from white people and denied Black citizens equal treatment. Hayden does not need to begin with a long historical explanation. The profile allows one child’s memory and one set of signs to make the system visible.
Childhood Fear and the Language of Segregation
Hayden reports that Lewis said he lived “in constant fear” as a little boy. This statement is emotionally direct, but it is not included merely to create sadness. It explains the atmosphere in which Lewis developed. Fear was produced by a social order that communicated exclusion through ordinary public language.
The signs read “no colored boys, no colored girls.” The wording is important because it addresses children specifically. The signs do not describe a distant political dispute; they tell young Black people that particular spaces are closed to them because of their race. The language turns discrimination into a visible rule encountered in everyday life.
Racial segregation is the enforced separation of people according to race. Discrimination is unequal treatment based on a characteristic such as race. The signs express both concepts: they separate Black children from others and deny them equal access. Their blunt wording also reveals how discrimination works rhetorically. A short public message can make exclusion seem routine, official, and unavoidable.
The signs matter because they are both evidence and symbol: evidence of the conditions Lewis faced and a symbol of the larger system that defined where Black people could go, how they were treated, and what society expected them to accept.
Family Guidance and Conflicting Expectations
Lewis’s parents and grandparents helped him interpret these conditions. They told him, “don’t get in trouble.” Their advice reflects a protective response to a dangerous environment. Adults who understood the risks of segregation warned a child to avoid actions that might bring punishment or violence.
At the same time, the advice creates a tension at the center of the paragraph. Lewis eventually became an activist, yet his family urged caution. This is not a contradiction that the profile needs to resolve by portraying the family as unsupportive. Their warning shows how discriminatory conditions shaped family decisions. They were trying to protect him within a system that could punish Black people for challenging racial rules.
The profile therefore presents activism as a development rather than a simple personality trait. Lewis’s later public courage becomes more meaningful when readers understand the fear and caution surrounding his childhood. His activism required him to move beyond the boundaries that his family, acting out of concern, had encouraged him to observe.
From Childhood Experience to Activism
The paragraph then moves from Lewis’s childhood to his youth and identifies the Montgomery Bus Boycott as an important inspiration. The boycott began when Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat. Hayden uses this event as a bridge between Lewis’s early experience and his emerging commitment to activism.
This connection produces a clear overarching story. The profile does not attempt to recount every stage of Lewis’s life. Instead, it focuses on how a child who encountered segregation and fear became a young person inspired to challenge injustice. The paragraph’s limited space makes selection essential: each detail contributes to the movement from background, to emotional experience, to historical influence, to action.
Structure
The paragraph uses a chronological structure, meaning that it presents events in the order in which they occurred. It begins with Lewis’s childhood in rural Alabama, moves through his experience of fear and his family’s warnings, and ends with the inspiration he received from the Montgomery Bus Boycott. This timeline helps readers understand change over time.
Chronology is especially effective here because Hayden’s central idea concerns formation. The reader sees a relationship between early conditions and later purpose:
- Childhood in rural Alabama establishes Lewis’s social and economic background.
- Segregated signs explain the source of his fear.
- Parents and grandparents provide guidance for surviving those conditions.
- The Montgomery Bus Boycott introduces a model of resistance.
- Lewis’s later activism appears as a response shaped by experience and example.
The structure also combines storytelling with reporting. The paragraph tells a compact story, but it relies on reported information about Lewis, his family, the signs, Rosa Parks, and the boycott. This combination gives the profile both human immediacy and historical grounding. A purely factual list might inform readers but fail to show how the facts connect. A purely personal story might create emotion without explaining the larger context. Hayden joins the two.
The annotations draw attention to the relationship between structure and meaning. When a writer places childhood before activism, the reader is encouraged to interpret activism as connected to lived experience. If the paragraph began with the boycott and added childhood later, the emphasis might shift toward public history rather than personal development. Hayden’s order asks readers to see the public figure through the conditions that formed him.
Purpose, Language, Culture, and Expectation
Hayden’s purpose is commemorative and explanatory: she remembers John Lewis while showing why his life mattered. That purpose shapes the selection of details. The paragraph includes neither a complete biography nor an exhaustive account of segregation. Instead, it chooses details that reveal courage emerging from fear and historical pressure.
Language also shapes the profile’s effect. “Constant fear” communicates Lewis’s emotional experience in his own reported words, while “no colored boys, no colored girls” preserves the harsh specificity of the signs. These phrases should not be softened into vague language such as “he faced some difficulties.” Vague wording would conceal the racial purpose of the signs and weaken the historical truth of the account.
Culture and historical expectation matter as well. Readers may recognize Lewis as a civil rights leader, but Hayden asks them to remember the cultural world that preceded his public role: Black family life, rural Alabama, segregated spaces, and the tradition of responding to injustice. The profile respects the expectation that a remembrance should honor its subject, yet it does so through concrete circumstances rather than empty praise.
Further Reading
The listed sources situate Hayden’s profile within journalism, public history, and documentary storytelling. One cited source is Harper (2020). The reading also lists Ira Glass’s This American Life, attributed to WBEZ Chicago, a public-radio program associated with narrative reporting. Mark Hartsell’s “Journalism, behind Barbed Wire,” published in the Library of Congress Blog, appears as another listed source.
These sources signal that a profile may draw on different kinds of material. A writer can use an individual’s remembered words, journalistic reporting, institutional archives, and historical accounts. The goal is not to collect sources randomly but to connect evidence to the profile’s angle. In Hayden’s piece, the sources support a focused interpretation of Lewis’s early life and the forces that led him toward activism.
Works Cited
The works cited list identifies the full title and publication information for Hayden’s “Remembering John Lewis: The Power of ‘Good Trouble,’” published by the Library of Congress Blog on July 19, 2020. It also lists Harper (2020), Ira Glass’s This American Life from WBEZ Chicago, and Mark Hartsell’s “Journalism, behind Barbed Wire” from the Library of Congress Blog.
A works-cited list matters because a profile’s authority depends partly on traceable information. Readers should be able to distinguish the profile writer’s framing from the words, memories, and historical materials on which that framing rests. In this annotated reading, citation supports the same principle as the paragraph’s structure: individual details become more powerful when readers can understand where they come from and how they contribute to the larger story.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.

Source Materials
Study English Composition I on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages