From the free course English Composition I on Lykke
7.9 Portfolio: What the Arts Say About You
Key concepts: Portfolio · Tracing writing development · Reflecting on the development of composing · Composing process · Podcasts · Google Podcasts · Stitcher · TV shows · Amazon · The AV Club
By the end of this section the student can: Reflect in writing on the development of composing processes.; Explain how those processes affect your work.
7.9 Portfolio: What the Arts Say About You
A writing portfolio is more than a folder of finished assignments: it is a record of how a writer’s thinking and composing have changed over time. When you place drafts, revisions, notes, and final pieces together, you can see decisions that disappear when only the polished version remains.
LEARNING OUTCOMES
By the end of this work, you should be able to:
- Reflect in writing on the development of your composing processes.
- Explain how those processes affect your work.
The Portfolio: And So It Begins
In its simplest form, a writing portfolio is a collection of your writing kept in one binder or folder. The collection may represent several weeks, months, or even years. Its value comes from what the pieces reveal together: not only what you can write now, but also how you arrived there.
A portfolio therefore differs from a file of “best papers.” A best-paper collection emphasizes products. A portfolio focused on development emphasizes movement: an initial idea becoming a thesis, research or observation becoming evidence, a confusing paragraph becoming clearer, or a revision changing the way an audience understands a subject.
A portfolio traces writing development by showing the relationship between composing choices, revision, and the resulting work.
The word composing is deliberately broader than “writing a final draft.” A composing process includes choosing a subject, considering an audience, developing an evaluation, organizing ideas, selecting evidence, drafting, revising, editing, and deciding how the finished work should reach readers. These steps do not always occur in a neat sequence. A writer may discover a stronger thesis while drafting, return to research after recognizing a gap, or reorganize an introduction after seeing that the conclusion points in a different direction.
A portfolio makes those less-visible choices available for reflection. For example, a review writer might preserve an early note that says “I liked the film,” an exploratory paragraph comparing two scenes, a later thesis about the film’s representation of a community, and the final review. Read together, these artifacts show the movement from personal reaction to criteria, evidence, analysis, and a defensible evaluation.
Tracing Writing Development
Tracing writing development means looking across pieces and stages of work to identify patterns of change. The goal is not simply to announce that one paper is “better” than another. The goal is to explain what changed, why it changed, and what the change made possible.
Useful evidence for this tracing can include early topic lists, questions, notes, outlines, drafts, peer or instructor responses, revision plans, and final versions. Each artifact answers a different question. An early list may show how you selected a subject. A draft may show where your thinking was uncertain. A revision may show how you clarified your purpose or adjusted your organization for readers.
Consider this brief development:
At first, I chose the exhibition because I already enjoyed the artist’s work. After comparing three pieces, I changed my focus to how the exhibition places private memory beside public history. That shift gave me a clearer basis for evaluating its effect on visitors.
The reflection does more than report a sequence of events. It identifies an initial motivation, describes a change in focus, and explains the consequence of that change. “I liked it” is a reaction; “the exhibition places private memory beside public history” is an analytical direction. The portfolio allows the writer to show how a personal interest became a focused piece of writing.
Development can also involve difficulties. A writer may discover that a topic is too broad, that an evaluation is obvious but unsupported, or that a paragraph contains several ideas competing for attention. These problems are not evidence that composing failed. They are evidence of the decisions composing requires. A thoughtful portfolio names such problems and explains the strategies used to address them.
Reflecting on the Development of the Composing Process
A reflection is writing that examines an experience and interprets its significance. In a portfolio, reflection turns a collection of documents into an account of learning. It asks you to move beyond “what I wrote” toward “how I composed” and “how my process affected the work.”
Strong reflection connects process to outcome. Instead of writing, “I revised my introduction,” a writer might explain, “My first introduction began with background about film criticism, but it delayed my evaluation. I replaced it with the judgment I wanted readers to understand, then used the following paragraphs to establish the criteria and evidence behind that judgment.” This explanation identifies the choice, the problem, the revision, and the effect on the reader.
The review-writing task offers especially useful material for this reflection. A review requires more than stating whether something is enjoyable. The writer chooses a subject, determines what makes it successful or unsuccessful, gathers relevant details, and develops an evaluation that an audience can understand. Looking back, you can ask how your composing process shaped each of those decisions.
Choosing a Topic
One important question is: On what basis did you choose your topic? You may have selected it because you were genuinely interested, because it was familiar, because it raised a question, or because another motivation directed your choice. The purpose is not to defend the topic as the “right” one. The purpose is to understand how the starting point influenced the writing that followed.
For instance, choosing a television show because you already know its characters may make description easier, but familiarity can also make assumptions invisible. Choosing an unfamiliar work may require more background and careful observation, but it may encourage sharper questions. A reflection can recognize both the advantage and the limitation.
Podcasts can provide another form of arts-related material for composing and reflection. Students can access podcasts through Google Podcasts and Stitcher. The important portfolio question is not merely which platform supplied the material. It is how the medium, subject, and intended audience affected your choices as a writer: what details you noticed, what context you supplied, and how you shaped the review for readers who might not share your familiarity.
Developing an Evaluation and Thesis
Ask whether your evaluation and thesis seemed obvious from the beginning or required thought before you settled on them. An initial judgment may be immediate, while the reasoning behind it develops gradually. That difference matters because a persuasive review must explain why the judgment is warranted.
A weak starting point might be: “The podcast is interesting.” A developing thesis could become: “The podcast is most effective when its conversational interviews make a complicated artistic debate accessible without oversimplifying it.” The second statement gives the writer something to examine: the interviews, the explanation of complexity, and the effect on an audience. A portfolio reflection can show how that sharper evaluation emerged from listening, comparing episodes, or reconsidering an early reaction.
TV-show resources such as Amazon, The AV Club, and the Internet Movie Database can also become part of the writer’s working environment. Their different purposes and audiences may offer descriptions, contextual information, credits, ratings, or critical responses. In a portfolio, these materials can help you explain how you decided what information belonged in your own writing and how you distinguished your evaluation from someone else’s.
Personal Appeal and Composing Difficulty
Another question asks: What made this topic personally appealing? Personal appeal can sustain attention, but it does not replace analysis. A subject may matter because it connects to your experiences, interests, values, or curiosity. Reflection explains how that connection influenced your attention and your decisions without treating personal enthusiasm as sufficient evidence.
You should also identify what was easy and what was hard about composing the essay. The easy parts might include generating observations, describing a familiar work, or recognizing an initial response. The difficult parts might include narrowing the topic, moving from opinion to criteria, selecting evidence, organizing the discussion, or revising a thesis that no longer fit the draft.
A useful reflection makes difficulty specific. “The essay was hard” gives no account of the process. “I could describe several episodes, but I struggled to explain what connected them. I solved the problem by grouping my observations according to two evaluation criteria rather than discussing the episodes in viewing order” shows a composing decision and its effect on organization.
How Composing Processes Affect Your Work
The central portfolio insight is that process and product are connected. A narrow topic can produce a more focused evaluation. A revised thesis can change the order of an essay. More deliberate attention to audience can determine how much background a reader needs. Careful selection of evidence can turn an enthusiastic response into a credible judgment.
Your reflection should therefore treat writing as a series of purposeful choices rather than as a mysterious talent. Compare early and later work, point to concrete changes, and explain the consequences. The portfolio becomes most meaningful when it shows not only what you composed, but also how your composing decisions shaped what your readers were able to see, understand, and judge.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.
Source Materials
Study English Composition I on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages