From the free course English Composition I on Lykke
7.4 Annotated Student Sample: "Black Representation in Film" by Caelia Marshall
Key concepts: Review genre conventions · Purpose, language, culture, and expectation · Relationships between ideas and patterns of organization · Black representation in film and television · Oppression and complicity in the erasure of Black characters and stories · Underrepresentation versus stereotypical racist representation · The stereotypical mammy figure · Power dynamics between a Black babysitter and a White male employer · Analysis of the name Killmonger · Connotation and characterization
By the end of this section the student can: Recognize key terms and features of review writing.; Explain how conventions of the review genre are shaped by purpose, language, culture, and expectation.; Analyze relationships between ideas and patterns of organization in written texts.
7.4 Annotated Student Sample: “Black Representation in Film” by Caelia Marshall
A film review can judge more than entertainment value: it can examine who appears on screen, who remains invisible, and what cultural assumptions guide an audience’s response. In “The Black Experience: What We See and Hear in Film,” Caelia Marshall reviews Rear Window (1954), Number 37 (2018), and Black Panther (2018) through the question of Black representation. Her review uses familiar film-review conventions—attention to scenes, characters, language, and effects—but directs those conventions toward a social argument about visibility, racism, and audience empathy.
Introduction
Marshall’s opening establishes both her subject and her critical perspective. Rather than treating the films only as artistic objects, she places them in the context of how Black people and Black culture are represented in film and television. The introduction begins with an attention-grabbing statistic about the enormous economic value of the film industry, then moves toward the question of who benefits from that industry’s stories and who is excluded from them.
This movement is important because a review needs more than a personal reaction. A reaction such as “I liked this movie” gives a reader a preference but not a reasoned evaluation. Marshall instead identifies a criterion—representation—and develops a judgment supported by examples from particular films. Her review therefore connects the conventional work of criticism with a broader cultural analysis.
A review becomes more powerful when its evaluation is shaped by a clear purpose: Marshall is not merely deciding whether the films are enjoyable, but examining what their representations teach audiences to see, overlook, or misunderstand.
The introduction presents Marshall’s central claim: oppression can be complicit, or actively involved, in keeping Black characters and Black stories hidden from view. The word “complicit” matters because it shifts the argument away from the idea that oppression exists only through openly hostile acts. A culture may also marginalize people through absence—by failing to tell their stories, failing to cast them in complex roles, or treating their experiences as unimportant.
Living by Their Own Words
Marshall’s review is organized around the relationship between what films show and what audiences learn from those images. Her concern is not simply whether Black people appear on screen. She asks how they appear, whether they possess complexity and agency, and whether audiences are invited to understand their experiences as fully human.
The review makes a deliberately challenging comparison. Marshall argues that the lack of Black representation in film and television can be more dangerous than stereotypical racist representation. At first, this claim may seem surprising. A stereotype is visibly harmful: it reduces people to familiar and degrading images such as the mammy, servant, or criminal. Absence, by contrast, may seem to say nothing. Marshall’s point is that absence can prevent audiences from encountering Black experiences at all.
Stereotypical representation gives audiences a distorted picture; underrepresentation can give them no picture. When Black characters and stories are missing, audiences may dismiss Black experiences as irrelevant, unusual, or nonexistent. Marshall connects that dismissal to reduced empathy: people are less likely to understand perspectives that stories never allow them to see.
What We See and What We Hear
Marshall’s discussion of Rear Window demonstrates how a reviewer can interpret a small performance detail as evidence of a larger cultural pattern. In the scene she analyzes, a Black babysitter answers her White male employer in the voice associated with the stereotypical mammy—the Black nursemaid historically represented as caring for White children, particularly in the American South.
The voice is not a neutral choice. It draws on a racist minstrel tradition, in which Black speech and behavior were exaggerated for White audiences’ amusement. Hitchcock appears to use the moment as comic relief during a tense confrontation between the protagonist, L. B. Jefferies, and the police chief. The humor depends on the audience recognizing the stereotype and treating it as funny.
Marshall’s analysis exposes the cost of that comic effect. The scene uses a Black character’s identity and speech as a punch line. Instead of allowing the babysitter to speak as an individual with her own perspective, the script calls upon a ready-made racist image. The scene therefore illustrates how representation can be present and still be dehumanizing.
Representation is not automatically meaningful or respectful merely because a group appears. A character can be visible while being confined to a stereotype.
This example gives Marshall evidence for distinguishing underrepresentation from stereotypical representation. Underrepresentation erases or minimizes Black experiences. Stereotypical representation includes Black people but limits them to roles that serve someone else’s story, humor, or expectations. The two problems differ, but both shape what audiences believe Black people can be.
Black Panther
Marshall’s analysis of Black Panther shows another review technique: interpreting a character’s name as a meaningful element of the film’s argument. She examines the name Killmonger, focusing especially on the word “monger.” In its basic sense, “monger” means a vendor or dealer. However, the word often carries a negative connotation, meaning an association that gives it an unfavorable emotional or moral force.
In “Killmonger,” the negative connotation suggests someone who deals aggressively in an undesirable product. The name therefore does more than identify a character. It frames him through language before the audience has fully considered his history, motives, or political claims. Marshall treats the name as part of the film’s pattern of meaning, showing how a reviewer can move from a specific word to a larger interpretation.
Marshall also connects Killmonger’s anger to his personal and political history. As a young person, he loses his Black militant father, who was living in the United States as a Wakandan emissary. His later fight against Wakanda represents an attempt to reclaim what he believes his father lost: the ability to arm poor Black people throughout the world in a struggle for civil rights.
This interpretation complicates a simple hero-versus-villain reading. Killmonger’s methods and aggression may be condemned, but his anger emerges from a recognizable history of abandonment, racial injustice, and unequal power. Marshall’s attention to his name and background demonstrates how representation can make a character available for analysis rather than reducing him to a single label.
Purpose, Language, Culture, and Audience Expectations
Review-genre conventions are shaped by purpose, language, culture, and audience expectations. A reviewer chooses what to emphasize according to the judgment the review intends to make. A review written to help viewers choose an entertaining film may focus on pacing, acting, or plot. Marshall’s purpose is broader: she evaluates films as cultural texts that influence ideas about Black life and identity.
Language makes that purpose visible. Terms such as “oppression,” “complicit,” “stereotypical,” “representation,” and “connotation” guide readers toward a social and interpretive reading. Marshall does not treat words, voices, names, or casting decisions as accidental details. She explains how they carry cultural histories and how those histories affect audience expectations.
Culture also determines what an audience may recognize. A viewer familiar with the history of the mammy stereotype may understand the babysitter’s voice as more than a joke. A viewer who does not know that history may see only comic performance. The reviewer’s work includes making the cultural meaning of the scene legible, so readers can evaluate an effect they might otherwise overlook.
Audience expectations can preserve stereotypes. If viewers expect Black characters to appear as servants, criminals, comic figures, or background figures, familiar portrayals may seem “natural” even when they are historically constructed. Conversely, a film such as Black Panther can challenge expectations by centering Black characters, cultures, conflicts, and futures. Marshall’s review asks readers to notice how those expectations are created and either reinforced or disrupted.
Relationships Between Ideas and Patterns of Organization
Readers should analyze how ideas relate to patterns of organization in written texts. Marshall’s review does not present disconnected observations. It moves from the general problem of representation to particular film scenes, then uses those scenes to develop a larger claim about visibility, stereotypes, and empathy.
The organization works partly through comparison. Marshall places older and newer examples alongside one another: Rear Window illustrates a stereotypical representation, while Black Panther provides a different setting for examining Black identity, conflict, and political meaning. The comparison does not imply that every film fits neatly into one category. Instead, it helps readers distinguish forms of representation and evaluate their different effects.
The review also follows a pattern of claim, evidence, and interpretation. Marshall makes a claim about racism or erasure, identifies a concrete feature—a voice, a scene, or a name—and explains what that feature means in cultural context. This structure prevents the essay from becoming a list of opinions. Each example performs a job in the argument.
A useful way to see the pattern is:
- Claim: absence can erase Black experiences, while stereotypes can distort them.
- Evidence: the babysitter uses the voice of the mammy stereotype; Killmonger’s name carries a negative meaning.
- Analysis: these choices shape how audiences understand Black characters and their histories.
- Evaluation: films should be judged not only by entertainment value but also by the cultural effects of their representations.
The annotated sample therefore models a review that is evaluative, analytical, and culturally aware. Its most important choice is to treat representation as something audiences learn from, not merely something they watch. By connecting purpose, language, culture, audience expectations, and organization, Marshall shows how a film review can evaluate entertainment while also asking who is allowed to be seen, heard, and understood.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.


Source Materials
Study English Composition I on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages