From the free course English Composition I on Lykke
6.5 Writing Process: Creating a Proposal
Key concepts: proposal writing process · rhetorical situation · planning and organization · thesis statement · proposal organization · evidence · introduction · possible solutions · potential objections · recommendations
By the end of this section the student can: Describe the elements of the rhetorical situation for your proposal.; Apply prewriting strategies to discover a problem to write about.; Gather and synthesize information from appropriate sources.; Draft a thesis statement and create an organizational plan.; Compose a proposal that develops your ideas and integrates evidence from sources.; Implement strategies for drafting, peer reviewing, and revising.
6.5 Writing Process: Creating a Proposal
A proposal persuades readers to consider a problem seriously and to support a practical course of action. Its success depends not only on having a worthwhile idea, but also on understanding the rhetorical situation, organizing the reasoning clearly, and supporting each major claim with evidence.
The Proposal Writing Process
Most writers move through three broad stages: planning and organization, drafting, and review. These stages are not rigid boxes. Writers may move backward when research changes their understanding of the problem, when feedback reveals a missing explanation, or when a thesis no longer matches the evidence. Still, beginning with purposeful planning makes the proposal easier to develop.
During planning, consider the rhetorical situation, understand the assignment, gather ideas and evidence, draft a tentative thesis, and create an organizational plan. Drafting begins when you have a workable understanding of the problem, the possible solutions, the evidence available, and the order in which readers should encounter your ideas. Review then gives you an opportunity to seek feedback and revise clarity, connections, organization, and the thesis itself.
A proposal is strongest when its problem, evidence, solution, and recommendation work together as one line of reasoning.
Considering the Rhetorical Situation
The rhetorical situation is the set of circumstances in which a writer communicates with an audience about a subject. It includes the writer’s purpose, the readers, the genre, and the expectations of the community and culture in which the writing takes place. A proposal written to a city council, for example, will make different choices from a proposal written to college students, even if both address the same problem.
Begin by asking questions about the topic. Is the problem and solution assigned, or may you choose them? What do you want to know more about? What requirements must you meet? Will research be necessary? These questions help you control the scope of the project. A topic such as “college transportation” is broad; a more manageable problem might be unreliable evening transportation for students who work off campus.
Next, consider context. What problems in your city, county, state, region, nation, or the world need attention? What current events or new information relate to the issue? Is your college or university connected to the problem? Context affects both urgency and feasibility. A proposal about campus food waste, for instance, might address local dining practices rather than attempting to solve food waste everywhere.
Culture and community also matter. Readers bring shared values, assumptions, experiences, and expectations to a proposal. A recommendation that seems obvious to one group may seem expensive, impractical, or unfair to another. Identifying those perspectives early helps you anticipate what readers will need explained and what objections they may raise.
Finally, analyze the audience and presentation. Who will read the proposal? What does that audience already know? What does it value? Does it have the authority or resources to act? Will the proposal be submitted as a formal document, presented orally, or shared in another form? These decisions influence vocabulary, amount of background information, tone, evidence, and level of detail.
Planning and Organization
Planning transforms a large subject into a sequence of answerable questions. Start by gathering possible problems, causes, effects, stakeholders, and solutions. Then distinguish between what you know, what you believe, and what you still need to investigate. Facts and evidence can support a proposal, but unsupported opinions cannot substitute for them.
A useful planning process is to identify the problem, explain why it matters, investigate possible causes, list people or groups affected by it, and research solutions that could realistically address it. This process prevents a common mistake: proposing an appealing action before demonstrating that the action responds to the actual problem.
Organization gives the developing proposal a shape that readers can follow. Your plan should show where the problem will be explained, where evidence will appear, how solutions will be compared, where objections will be answered, and how the recommendation will emerge. Planning does not eliminate revision; it gives revision something concrete to improve.
Drafting a Thesis
A thesis statement states the proposal’s main idea. In a proposal, it normally identifies the action or position the writer wants readers to consider. Every paragraph should contribute to, explain, support, qualify, or defend that central idea.
A proposal thesis is a controlling claim: it guides the proposal’s paragraphs and keeps the discussion focused on a particular course of action.
A tentative thesis is useful even before every detail is settled. It gives research a direction while remaining open to revision. For example, “Campus transportation is a problem” identifies an issue but does not yet make a proposal. “The college should extend evening shuttle service on weekdays because students who work late lack a reliable way to return safely” is more useful because it identifies an action and begins to indicate why that action matters.
After drafting a thesis, ask whether it is engaging. Does it present a meaningful problem? Does it suggest a solution readers can imagine supporting? Does it offer a specific position rather than merely announcing a topic? If the thesis is dull, vague, or predictable, revise it. An engaging thesis does not need to be dramatic; it needs to give readers a clear reason to continue.
Organizing Your Ideas
A proposal should have a recognizable structure. Readers generally expect an introduction, a discussion of the problem, possible solutions, potential objections, and a conclusion containing a recommendation. This structure is flexible, but omitting one of these functions can leave readers uncertain about what is wrong, what could be done, or what action the writer supports.
The following organization provides a practical working plan:
| Proposal part | Main function |
|---|---|
| Introduction | Presents the problem and establishes the proposal’s direction |
| Problem discussion | Explains the problem, its significance, causes, effects, and affected stakeholders |
| Possible solutions | Describes feasible responses and supports them with evidence |
| Potential objections | Recognizes concerns about the proposed solutions and responds to them |
| Conclusion | Recommends a course of action and reinforces why it should be taken |
Use the outline as a reasoning tool rather than as a collection of empty headings. Under “problem,” note the evidence that demonstrates the problem exists. Under each solution, record the evidence showing how it could help, what it would require, and what limitations it might have. Under “objections,” identify the strongest reasonable concerns, not exaggerated versions that are easy to dismiss.
Developing Paragraphs with Evidence
Each body paragraph should have a clear purpose and enough evidence to support it. Evidence may include facts, statistics, examples, expert statements, research findings, or other relevant information. The important question is not simply whether a source appears, but whether the evidence actually supports the paragraph’s claim.
A paragraph about transportation might begin with a claim about the consequences of limited evening service, present evidence about students’ work schedules or transportation difficulties, and then explain how that evidence supports the proposed change. The explanation matters because readers should not have to guess why a statistic or example belongs in the argument.
Evidence also helps writers avoid treating personal opinion as proof. A writer may believe that extending shuttle hours would improve student safety, but the proposal should investigate relevant information and explain the connection rather than relying on belief alone. Credible evidence makes the proposal more persuasive and allows readers to evaluate the recommendation.
Presenting Possible Solutions
Describe possible solutions one at a time. Give each solution enough space for readers to understand what it involves, how it addresses the problem, what resources it requires, and what advantages or limitations it has. Moving rapidly from one solution to another can make the proposal feel like a list rather than a reasoned evaluation.
A proposal may present several possibilities before recommending one. For example, a transportation proposal might consider extending shuttle hours, creating a late-night partnership with a local transit service, or subsidizing rides for students with demonstrated need. Discussing each option separately makes comparison possible and prepares readers for the final recommendation.
Potential objections belong inside the reasoning, not outside it. Readers may worry about cost, staffing, fairness, effectiveness, or unintended consequences. Addressing these concerns shows that the writer understands the complexity of the issue. A strong response may concede a genuine limitation and then explain why the solution remains worthwhile or how the limitation can be reduced.
Drafting the Proposal
Begin drafting after developing a tentative thesis, an organization plan, and evidence. At that point, drafting becomes more than placing sentences on a page: it becomes the process of turning a planned argument into a readable explanation for a particular audience.
Introduction
The introduction presents the problem to be addressed. It should draw readers in, make the topic clear, and remain concise. The introduction may be written first, last, or midway through drafting. Writing it later can be especially useful because the writer then understands the proposal’s most important points.
The thesis often appears at the end of the introduction. This placement gives readers the necessary context before stating the proposal’s main idea. For example, an introduction might briefly establish the difficulty students face when returning from evening jobs, identify the limits of current transportation, and end by proposing extended weekday shuttle service.
Problem Discussion
The problem discussion explains what is happening and why it requires attention. It may examine causes, effects, seriousness, and stakeholders. The writer should not assume that naming a problem proves its importance. Readers need evidence and explanation showing how the problem affects people or institutions and why existing conditions are inadequate.
Solutions, Objections, and Recommendation
After establishing the problem, present possible solutions individually and support the discussion with evidence. Then address potential objections. The conclusion should offer a recommendation, meaning a proposed course of action. A recommendation is more specific than a general hope for improvement: it tells readers what should be done and, ideally, why that action is preferable to the alternatives.
The conclusion should not introduce an entirely new problem or unsupported solution. Instead, it should gather the proposal’s reasoning: the problem matters, the evidence supports a particular response, objections have been considered, and the recommended action is a reasonable next step.
Writing the Abstract or Executive Summary
An abstract or executive summary appears first in the finished proposal, but it is advisable to write it after completing the proposal. Only then can you accurately identify the proposal’s main points and represent them briefly.
A useful executive summary states the proposal’s purpose, identifies the problem, gives essential context or causes, and indicates the suggested solutions. It does not reproduce the entire proposal or provide every piece of evidence. Its job is to let a busy reader understand the proposal’s direction quickly.
For example, an executive summary about the small number of women in information technology would identify the purpose of examining that imbalance, mention factors such as stereotypes, limited role models, family responsibilities, and lack of advancement, and point toward solutions such as encouraging girls’ interest, recruiting college students, mentoring professional women, and improving workplace flexibility. The summary presents the main logic without replacing the detailed discussion that follows.
Reviewing and Revising
With a first draft complete, seek feedback and ask focused questions. Is the thesis clear? Does every paragraph support or develop it? Does the organization lead readers from problem to solution to recommendation? Are ideas connected clearly? Does the evidence support the claims? Do potential objections receive a fair response?
Revision may require more than correcting sentences. You may need to change the order of sections, expand an explanation, remove an unsupported claim, strengthen evidence, or revise the thesis so that it accurately represents the proposal. A polished proposal is not merely a corrected first draft; it is a clearer and more credible version of the reasoning.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.
Source Materials
Study English Composition I on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages