From the free course English Composition I on Lykke

6.9 Portfolio: Reflecting on Problems and Solutions

By the end of this section the student can: Reflect in writing on the development of your writing process.; Reflect in writing on how the writing process affected your work.; Reflect in writing on your objectivity as a writer.

6.9 Portfolio: Reflecting on Problems and Solutions

A proposal does not end when its final recommendation is written. Its full value becomes visible when the writer can explain how the proposal developed: how the problem was defined, which evidence shaped the argument, why one solution seemed more workable than another, and what the writing process revealed about the writer’s own decisions. A portfolio gathers that work and makes the development of the proposal visible.

A useful way to imagine a portfolio is as both an archive and an argument. The archive preserves stages of work—notes, research, drafts, feedback, revisions, and the final proposal. The argument is the writer’s reflection explaining what changed and why those changes improved the response to the problem. The portfolio therefore does more than display a finished paper; it demonstrates deliberate problem-solving and rhetorical judgment.

The Purpose of a Portfolio

A portfolio is a purposeful collection of writing and related materials that shows a writer’s progress, choices, and learning. In a proposal-writing portfolio, the central artifact is the problem-solution proposal, but the supporting materials matter because they reveal the reasoning behind the final version.

A polished proposal can hide the uncertainty involved in producing it. The final document may appear to move smoothly from problem to solution, even though the writer probably changed the topic, rejected sources, revised the definition of the problem, reorganized evidence, or discovered that an attractive solution was not feasible. Reflection makes those invisible decisions explainable.

The portfolio also gives the writer an opportunity to assess the proposal as a rhetorical act. A proposal responds to a real or imagined audience that may be affected by the problem, have authority to act, or need convincing that action is worthwhile. Reflecting on the portfolio means asking whether the proposal’s purpose, evidence, organization, tone, and recommendation fit that audience.

What Belongs in the Portfolio

The exact contents of a portfolio depend on the assignment, but a strong collection normally includes the major stages of the writing process. These materials should not appear as unrelated leftovers. Each item should help show how the writer moved from recognizing a problem to developing and evaluating a solution.

Important portfolio materials may include:

  • An early topic proposal or exploratory writing that shows how the problem first came into focus.
  • Notes, questions, or research records that document the search for information.
  • Sources or source summaries used to establish facts, causes, effects, and stakeholder perspectives.
  • An early draft of the proposal.
  • Peer or instructor feedback, especially comments that led to substantial revision.
  • A revised or final proposal.
  • A reflective statement explaining the writer’s choices, changes, strengths, and next steps.

The portfolio should show development, not merely accumulation. Including five drafts without explaining their differences does not automatically demonstrate learning. A brief note can establish the significance of each artifact: an early draft might show an overly broad problem, while a later draft might narrow the focus and connect the recommendation more directly to evidence.

Reflecting on the Problem

The first major object of reflection is the problem itself. Proposals become persuasive when they identify a problem precisely rather than treating a general concern as if it were already an argument. A writer should consider how the definition of the problem changed during research and whether the final version accounts for its complexity.

Complex problems often have multiple causes, effects, possible solutions, and stakeholders. Reflection should therefore address questions such as:

  • Did the original topic describe a problem clearly, or was it too broad?
  • What causes became visible through research?
  • Who experiences the problem, and who has the power or responsibility to respond?
  • What effects make the problem important?
  • Did research reveal perspectives that the initial understanding ignored?
  • Did the final proposal distinguish facts from opinions and assumptions?

For example, a writer might begin with “students do not read enough” and later recognize that this statement is too general to support a responsible proposal. Research may lead to a narrower problem, such as limited access to required course materials or a lack of quiet study spaces. The narrower definition creates room for specific evidence and a solution that an institution could realistically implement.

Reflection is strongest when it explains not only what the writer changed but why the change produced a more accurate and workable understanding of the problem.

Reflecting on Evidence and Bias

A proposal depends on evidence, but evidence does not speak for itself. Writers select sources, interpret information, and decide which facts deserve emphasis. A portfolio reflection should examine those choices, including the writer’s efforts to recognize bias in sources and in the writer’s own assumptions.

A fact can be checked against reliable evidence; an opinion expresses a judgment or belief. The distinction matters because a proposal may use both, but it should not present an opinion as an established fact. For instance, “the library has fewer evening hours than last year” is a factual claim if supported by records. “The library’s schedule is unreasonable” is an evaluation that requires criteria and explanation.

A reflective statement might explain that the writer initially searched only for information supporting a preferred solution, then broadened the research to consider objections and alternatives. That change demonstrates critical thinking. It also makes the final proposal more credible because the recommendation appears to have survived comparison rather than being selected before the investigation began.

A useful reflection can identify evidence that was especially influential:

  • Which statistic clarified the scale or urgency of the problem?
  • Which source explained a cause or consequence?
  • Which stakeholder perspective complicated the writer’s original position?
  • Which evidence supported the feasibility of the recommendation?
  • What evidence was missing or difficult to locate?
  • How did the writer decide whether a source was credible and relevant?

Reflecting on the Solution

A solution is not strong merely because it sounds desirable. An effective proposal recommends an action that responds to identified causes, considers affected stakeholders, and can plausibly be carried out. Reflection should test the connection between the problem and the recommendation.

Suppose a proposal identifies transportation costs as a barrier to student employment and recommends expanded campus shuttle service. The reflection should explain why transportation was treated as a significant cause, how the proposed service addresses that cause, and what limitations remain. It might also acknowledge costs, scheduling conflicts, environmental effects, or students whose needs the shuttle would not meet.

This kind of acknowledgment does not weaken a proposal. It shows that the writer understands solutions as decisions involving trade-offs. A recommendation becomes more convincing when it recognizes likely objections and responds to them with evidence or practical adjustments.

Reflecting on Rhetorical Choices

Reflection should also examine the proposal’s rhetorical choices. Rhetoric here means the deliberate use of communication to address an audience and achieve a purpose. The writer can discuss how the proposal’s organization, tone, evidence, and level of explanation were shaped by the intended readers.

For example, a proposal addressed to campus administrators may emphasize costs, implementation, policy, and measurable outcomes. A proposal addressed to students may spend more time describing lived effects and inviting participation. Neither audience is automatically better; the important question is whether the choices fit the people who must understand, approve, or act on the recommendation.

A reflection might state:

I moved the discussion of cost earlier because the intended decision-makers would need to know whether the recommendation was feasible before considering its broader benefits. I also replaced several emotional claims with documented effects so that the proposal would appeal to an audience responsible for evaluating evidence and allocating resources.

This example does more than announce revision. It identifies a rhetorical problem, names the change, and explains the reasoning behind it.

Reflecting on Revision

Revision means more than correcting grammar or replacing a few words. In proposal writing, substantial revision may involve redefining the problem, reorganizing the argument, adding or removing evidence, changing the recommended solution, or adjusting the proposal for its audience. Editing improves correctness and clarity; revision rethinks the writing’s ideas and structure.

A productive reflection identifies specific changes between drafts. Compare these two statements:

  • “I revised my paper and fixed some mistakes.”
  • “My first draft treated food insecurity as a matter of individual budgeting. After researching local food access and reading stakeholder perspectives, I revised the proposal to address transportation and neighborhood availability as structural causes.”

The second statement demonstrates learning because it connects revision to new understanding. It shows that research changed not just the wording but the writer’s interpretation of the problem and the kind of solution that could address it.

Writing the Reflective Statement

A reflective statement should be specific, organized, and evidence-based. It is not a diary entry and should not simply praise the final paper. The writer’s own portfolio supplies the evidence: drafts, comments, research notes, and changes in organization or wording.

An effective reflection can be organized around four movements:

  1. Describe the starting point. Explain the original problem, purpose, audience, or approach.
  2. Identify important discoveries. Discuss research findings, stakeholder perspectives, or challenges that changed the writer’s thinking.
  3. Analyze major revisions. Point to concrete changes and explain how they improved accuracy, feasibility, clarity, or persuasion.
  4. Assess current strengths and future goals. Identify what the proposal does well and what the writer would continue to improve.

A concise model might sound like this:

My initial proposal focused on reducing plastic waste through individual behavior, but research showed that purchasing systems and institutional policies shaped waste more strongly than I had assumed. I revised the problem statement, added evidence about campus purchasing, and recommended a reusable-container program rather than relying only on student reminders. The final proposal is more specific and feasible, although I would strengthen it by locating a clearer estimate of implementation costs.

The model works because it connects the writer’s changing understanding to concrete choices. It also admits a limitation without abandoning the proposal’s achievements.

Evaluating Growth as a Problem-Solver

The deepest portfolio reflection considers how the writer’s approach to problem-solving developed. The writer can ask whether research became more careful, whether competing perspectives received fair attention, and whether recommendations became more evidence-based and realistic.

Growth may appear in several forms:

  • Moving from a broad complaint to a focused, researchable problem.
  • Distinguishing causes from symptoms.
  • Separating facts, interpretations, and opinions.
  • Recognizing personal or source bias.
  • Considering multiple stakeholders rather than a single viewpoint.
  • Choosing a solution because evidence supports it, not simply because it is appealing.
  • Revising in response to feedback and newly discovered information.
  • Making the proposal’s purpose and audience clearer.

The portfolio’s final question is therefore larger than “Is the proposal good?” It asks, “What does the proposal reveal about the way I investigate, evaluate, and respond to complex problems?” A strong response shows that writing has become an intentional process of inquiry: define the problem carefully, examine evidence critically, weigh possible actions, and revise the response as understanding changes.

Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.

Source Materials

Study English Composition I on Lykke

This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.

Add the free extensionSign in to open every section

All sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages

6.9 Portfolio: Reflecting on Problems and Solutions — English Composition I | Lykke