From the free course English Composition I on Lykke

8.2 Trailblazer

Key concepts: Distinguishing fact from opinion · Recognizing bias in sources · Evaluating objectivity, expertise, and credibility · Identifying omitted or glossed-over information · Critically analyzing images and supporting media · Confirmation bias and the false consensus effect · Using biographical texts as sources · Undercover reporting and experiential research · Barbara Ehrenreich’s investigative and activist writing · Informative writing and evidence-based reporting

By the end of this section the student can: Define the term myth buster and its connection to field research; Answer questions about what it means to investigate and report information; Gather information from a biographical text.

8.2 Trailblazer

A myth buster investigates a widely held belief and tests it against reliable evidence rather than accepting repetition as proof. The goal is not merely to announce that a belief is wrong; it is to determine what can be established as fact, what remains opinion, and what information may have been ignored or distorted.

Myth-Buster

A myth-busting report resembles field research because the writer begins with a question, gathers information from multiple sources, evaluates that information, and reports a conclusion supported by evidence. The writer acts less like someone repeating a rumor and more like an investigator examining a claim. A biographical text, for example, may provide information about a person’s actions, experiences, and influence, but the writer must still determine which details are factual, which descriptions express an interpretation, and which important details may have been left out.

The central distinction is between fact and opinion. A fact is information that can be checked against evidence. An opinion is a belief, judgment, or interpretation. Opinions are not automatically useless or dishonest; editorials and opinion pieces often state their purpose openly and are intentionally written to persuade. The problem arises when a source presents opinions as though they were neutral facts, or when a report gives readers no way to distinguish evidence from the writer’s conclusions.

Fact: a claim that can be verified with evidence.
Opinion: a belief, judgment, or interpretation that expresses a viewpoint.

Consider this short passage:

The city library opened in 1912 and now serves more than ten thousand residents each year. It is clearly the most valuable institution in the community.

The opening statement contains claims that can be checked through library records or municipal data. The final sentence is an opinion because “most valuable” expresses a judgment rather than a measurable fact. A careful writer might retain the judgment if the report is analyzing community attitudes, but would identify it as an interpretation and support it with evidence rather than presenting it as self-evident truth.

Distinguishing fact from opinion also requires attention to quantity and balance. A source may contain several accurate facts but still guide readers toward a particular conclusion through its opinions, organization, and emphasis. When investigating a claim, note how many factual statements appear, how many opinions appear, and how the two are connected. The presence of facts does not automatically make an entire source objective.

Bias is a preconceived opinion about a subject, idea, person, or group. Writers can carry bias themselves, and sources can contain bias. Bias is not limited to obviously angry or openly political writing. A source becomes especially problematic when readers believe it is neutral, objective, and trustworthy even though it presents information in a way that attempts to sway their opinions.

A report and the evidence supporting it should not be heavily biased. This does not mean that every report must pretend that all perspectives are equally supported. Instead, the writer should recognize the source’s purpose, identify its viewpoint, and judge whether its evidence fairly represents the issue. A writer may use a strongly opinionated source, but should not mistake that source for an impartial account.

The first question to ask about a source is: What is the writer trying to do? A writer may be informing readers, persuading them, defending a position, criticizing an idea, or encouraging action. An editorial or opinion piece openly signals persuasion. A report may appear informational while still selecting facts and language that favor one conclusion.

For example:

The neighborhood’s reckless proposal would eliminate the only safe place for children to study.

The sentence may refer to a real proposal and a real library, but words such as “reckless” and “only safe place” are emotionally loaded. They encourage readers to judge the proposal before examining the evidence. A less charged version might read:

The proposal would reduce the library’s after-school hours, which supporters say will lower costs and opponents say will limit students’ access to study space.

The revision does not remove the conflict. It identifies the practical effect of the proposal and acknowledges competing perspectives. It also avoids treating either side’s interpretation as an established fact. This is the kind of careful distinction a writer needs when investigating and reporting information.

The author’s identity and expertise also matter. Expertise means relevant knowledge or experience, while credibility means the degree to which a source deserves trust. Research the author: Is the writer recognized as an expert? Is the writer known for consistently taking one side? Does the author have relevant training, experience, or access to reliable evidence? Expertise can strengthen a source, but it does not make every claim automatically true. A recognized expert may still write for a persuasive purpose or overlook information.

A source’s title, introduction, and headings can reveal its approach before the reader reaches the central evidence. Headings may emphasize danger, success, failure, cost, or personal responsibility. The introduction may frame the issue so that one conclusion seems natural. Examine what the source highlights and what it treats as unimportant. The writer’s language often reveals the intended direction of the argument.

A myth-busting writer should also look for information that a source omits or glosses over. To gloss over information is to mention it briefly or vaguely without examining its importance. A source may present several facts that support its position while leaving out credible evidence that complicates the argument. Reading multiple sources helps reveal these gaps and makes it easier to locate credible views that the first source does not include.

Suppose one article reports that tuition-free college increases graduation rates but says nothing about eligibility rules, funding, completion costs, or students who do not benefit. The article may contain accurate statistics, yet its treatment of the issue remains incomplete. A second source might provide the missing context. Comparing both sources does not require choosing the source that agrees with you; it requires determining what each source includes, excludes, emphasizes, or assumes.

Supporting media, including photographs, charts, illustrations, and other images, also requires critical analysis. An image can influence interpretation through its subject, angle, caption, scale, cropping, and placement. Ask what the image shows, what it leaves outside the frame, and whether its caption accurately identifies its relevance. A photograph of a crowded classroom might support a claim about limited space, but it cannot by itself establish how often the room is crowded or why the crowding occurs. The image is evidence to interpret, not a substitute for investigation.

The same principle applies to charts and other visual evidence. Check what information is measured, what period is represented, what categories are compared, and whether the design makes one difference appear more dramatic than it is. A visual can be factually based while still directing attention toward one interpretation. The writer must examine both the underlying information and the presentation.

Writers must also recognize bias in themselves. Confirmation bias is the tendency to notice, accept, or seek information that supports a belief already held while ignoring or dismissing information that challenges it. A writer who begins with a strong position may judge supporting sources as “reasonable” and opposing sources as “biased,” even when both sources use comparable evidence.

The section connects confirmation bias to the false consensus effect, the tendency to overestimate how many other people agree with one’s beliefs. A person may assume that a preferred policy is obviously popular because friends, family members, or selected media sources support it. That assumption is not evidence of broad agreement. The writer must investigate what people actually believe rather than treating a familiar viewpoint as the majority position.

The example of tuition-free public colleges illustrates this danger. A writer who already believes college tuition is too high may readily accept statistics showing that tuition-free college improves graduation rates and financial security. The writer may regard those sources as mainstream or sensible because they confirm an existing belief. A responsible investigation must also examine credible information that raises difficulties, limitations, costs, or opposing conclusions.

A practical myth-busting process therefore asks several connected questions:

  • What is the claim, and which parts of it are verifiable facts?
  • Which statements are opinions, interpretations, or attempts to persuade?
  • What is the writer’s purpose?
  • What do the author’s expertise, affiliations, and reputation suggest about credibility?
  • Does the language use emotionally loaded or inflammatory words?
  • What do the title, introduction, and headings emphasize?
  • What information or credible perspectives might be omitted or glossed over?
  • Do images and other media provide relevant evidence, or do they mainly shape the reader’s emotional response?
  • Am I accepting this information because it confirms what I already believe?
  • Am I assuming that many people agree with me merely because people around me do?

A concise example shows how these questions work together:

Many residents oppose the new transit plan because it will make commuting worse. The plan’s supporters point to faster service, but they ignore the neighborhoods that will lose direct routes. A review of the proposal, transportation data, and statements from residents shows that the plan improves travel time for some riders while increasing transfers for others.

The passage distinguishes an initial claim from evidence that can be checked. It identifies the persuasive language in “make commuting worse,” acknowledges a competing perspective, and investigates what may have been overlooked. Most importantly, it avoids the false consensus effect: it does not treat one group’s view as the view of all residents. The conclusion is qualified because the evidence supports a mixed result rather than a simple myth that the plan is either entirely beneficial or entirely harmful.

A strong myth buster does not merely replace one certainty with another. The writer investigates, compares sources, identifies bias, checks expertise and credibility, distinguishes fact from opinion, examines omissions and media, and tests personal assumptions. The final report becomes more trustworthy when its conclusions match the evidence’s actual complexity.

Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.

Source Materials

Study English Composition I on Lykke

This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.

Add the free extensionSign in to open every section

All sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages

8.2 Trailblazer — English Composition I | Lykke