From the free course English Composition I on Lykke

6.1 Proposing Change: Thinking Critically About Problems and Solutions

Key concepts: Adopting a problem-solving mindset · Using critical-thinking questions to explore a proposal · Gathering information through reading, viewing, and research · Distinguishing facts from opinions · Using facts as evidence in a proposal · Evaluating source credibility, especially on social media platforms · Recognizing bias in sources and language · Recognizing personal cognitive bias, including confirmation bias · Considering audience, purpose, and stakeholders · Developing and evaluating possible solutions to problems

By the end of this section the student can: Ask critical-thinking questions about problems to explore an idea for a proposal.; Distinguish between fact and opinion.; Recognize and locate bias in reading and in yourself.

6.1 Proposing Change: Thinking Critically About Problems and Solutions

A proposal is more than a statement that something is wrong: it investigates a problem, explains why it matters, and recommends a solution that someone can realistically put into action. Like a careful mechanic, a proposal writer must diagnose the difficulty before suggesting a repair. “The campus wastes too much food” identifies a concern, but it does not yet explain what food is wasted, why it is discarded, how serious the problem is, or which people have the authority to change the situation.

A strong proposal therefore connects four questions: What is the problem? Why does it matter? What effects does it have? What solutions are possible? Complex problems may have several causes, consequences, possible solutions, and stakeholders—the people or groups affected by the problem or capable of addressing it. A proposal might concern campus transportation, mental-health services, food options, public-school funding, health-care access, environmental protection, or another issue that calls for organized action.

Adopting a Problem-Solving Mindset

A problem-solving mindset treats a concern as something to investigate rather than merely complain about. The writer begins by gathering information through reading, viewing, research, and conversations with others. Personal experience can help identify a meaningful topic, but it cannot by itself establish the full nature or extent of a problem.

Consider food waste on a college campus. A writer who believes reducing food waste is important must investigate what food is being thrown away and why. Are students leaving food on their plates? Are faculty members and employees discarding meals because portions are too large, schedules are unpredictable, or dining options do not meet their needs? What happens to unused food? What methods have other institutions tried? Which campus offices, dining services, student organizations, or administrators could carry out a solution?

The investigation changes the proposal’s quality. Without research, “We should reduce food waste” remains a general preference. With research, the writer may discover a specific pattern and address it with a solution suited to the people involved. The goal is not to make the problem sound dramatic; it is to understand the problem accurately enough to recommend a workable response.

A proposal writer should also resist the impulse to settle on a solution too early. The first attractive idea may not address the actual cause, may have been tried unsuccessfully, or may require authority and resources that the intended audience does not possess. Critical thinking keeps the writer’s attention on evidence, consequences, and feasibility.

Questions about Problems

Critical-thinking questions help transform a broad interest into a researchable proposal. Questions about the problem should examine its causes, effects, importance, and scope:

  • What is the cause of the problem?
  • What effect does the problem have?
  • What makes the problem important?
  • Who is affected by it?
  • What information is needed to understand it accurately?

For example, a writer investigating climate change might ask what causes it, what effects it produces, and what makes it a problem requiring action. These questions do not yet recommend a particular policy. Instead, they identify what the writer needs to learn before making a responsible recommendation.

This distinction matters because a visible symptom may not be the underlying problem. If a campus dining hall throws away large amounts of food, the cause might be inaccurate demand estimates, oversized portions, confusing meal-plan rules, or a lack of donation procedures. Each cause would point toward a different solution. A proposal that names only the symptom risks offering an impressive-sounding fix that leaves the cause untouched.

Questions about Solutions

Once the problem is understood, the writer examines possible responses. Useful questions include:

  • What solutions are possible?
  • What solutions have been tried in the past?
  • Did similar solutions succeed or fail?
  • Why did earlier solutions succeed or fail?
  • Who can put a solution into action?

These questions prevent a proposal from treating originality as the same thing as effectiveness. A solution does not have to be completely new; it may adapt an approach that worked elsewhere. Conversely, a popular idea may have failed before for reasons that still apply. Research into earlier attempts can reveal practical barriers, unexpected effects, costs, and conditions necessary for success.

In the climate-change example, the writer Shawn Krukowski began by asking about causes, effects, importance, possible solutions, previous attempts, reasons for failure, and the people able to act. Writing preliminary answers helped him identify what he needed to learn before beginning focused reading and research. This is a model of inquiry: questions guide the search for evidence, and evidence refines the eventual proposal.

The final question—who can act—is especially important. A recommendation addressed to classmates will differ from one addressed to campus administrators, a dining-service company, a local government, or a business. A proposal becomes practical when its recommended action matches the authority, resources, and responsibilities of its intended audience.

Distinguishing Fact from Opinion

A fact is information that can be checked or verified; an opinion is a belief, judgment, or recommendation. Proposals use both, but they use them for different purposes. Writers use facts as evidence to show that a problem is real and that a proposed solution can work. They use opinions—grounded in evidence—to recommend action and explain judgments.

Facts establish the situation; evidence-based opinions recommend what should happen next.

Compare these statements:

“In March 2020, 50 percent of Gen Z respondents ages 18–23 reported that they or someone in their household had lost a job or taken a pay cut.”

“Colleges should expand emergency financial-support programs for students.”

The first statement reports a finding attributed to the Pew Research Center. It functions as factual evidence about the economic effects of the first month of the COVID-19 pandemic. The second statement recommends an action. It is an opinion, but it need not be arbitrary: the writer can support it with the reported economic impact, additional research about student needs, and evidence about whether such programs work.

A common misconception is that a proposal should contain only opinions because proposals are persuasive. In fact, unsupported opinions weaken persuasion. Another misconception is that facts automatically produce a solution. Facts can demonstrate that a problem exists, but the writer must still reason from evidence to a feasible recommendation.

A useful working pattern is:

  1. Present verifiable information showing that the problem exists.
  2. Explain why the information matters and whom it affects.
  3. Recommend an action.
  4. Provide evidence that the action is possible and likely to help.

Recognizing Bias in Sources

Bias is a preference or slant that influences how information is presented. Readers can look for bias in a source’s language, title, introduction, headings, and treatment of the subject. Inflammatory words or descriptions may signal that a source is trying to provoke an emotional reaction rather than present information carefully. A source may also reveal bias by praising one side while ignoring or dismissing relevant opposing evidence.

This does not mean that every source must sound emotionless or that a source with a viewpoint is automatically useless. A source can offer valuable information while also reflecting a particular position. The critical reader asks what the source emphasizes, what it leaves out, what evidence it uses, and whether its conclusions match that evidence.

Social media requires especially careful evaluation because posts can circulate quickly, detach claims from their original context, and make opinions look like established facts. Before using a social-media claim in a proposal, examine who created it, what evidence supports it, when it was posted, and whether reliable independent sources confirm it. A confident tone, attractive graphic, or large number of shares does not establish credibility.

Recognizing Cognitive Bias in Yourself

Cognitive bias is the tendency to favor information that confirms an existing belief and to dismiss information that challenges it. This bias can affect proposal writers even when they sincerely want to be accurate. Critical reading therefore requires examining not only the source but also the reader’s own expectations.

Suppose a student believes the college has a very low graduation rate. While researching, the student may quickly accept a post claiming that graduation rates are disastrous, while rejecting an official report or carefully documented study showing a more complicated picture. The student is not simply comparing evidence; the student is favoring evidence that confirms an existing belief. To guard against confirmation bias, the writer should deliberately seek credible information that challenges the initial assumption and then evaluate all sources by the same standards.

A practical check is to ask: What did I expect to find? What evidence would challenge my view? Have I searched for that evidence? Am I calling a source “unreliable” only because I dislike its conclusion? These questions do not require the writer to abandon a position. They require the writer to earn that position through fair investigation.

Audience, Credibility, and Action

A proposal’s topic and presentation should account for its intended readers. An instructor may expect clearly documented research and a focused academic argument. Classmates may respond best to familiar examples and direct explanations. Students, campus administrators, and business audiences have different responsibilities, knowledge, resources, and authority. The same problem may therefore require different evidence, vocabulary, emphasis, and recommendations for different audiences.

Credibility grows when a proposal accurately describes the problem, distinguishes facts from opinions, acknowledges uncertainty, evaluates sources critically, and recommends an action that the audience can actually take. The writer’s task is not merely to declare that change is needed. It is to build a trustworthy chain of reasoning from evidence about the problem to a practical solution.

Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.

Source Materials

Study English Composition I on Lykke

This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.

Add the free extensionSign in to open every section

All sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages