From the free course English Composition I on Lykke
7.3 Glance at Genre: Criteria, Evidence, Evaluation
Key concepts: Genre · Criteria · Evidence · Evaluation · Reviewer credibility · Michiko Kakutani · Literary knowledge · Genre expertise · Reviewing others’ work
By the end of this section the student can: Identify and define common characteristics, mediums, key terms, and features of the review genre.; Identify criteria and evidence to support reviews of different primary sources.
7.3 Glance at Genre: Criteria, Evidence, Evaluation
A review does more than announce whether someone liked a book, film, performance, meal, or product: it makes a reasoned judgment about a specific subject. That judgment becomes useful only when readers can see the standards behind it, the evidence supporting it, and the reviewer’s knowledge of the subject. A review therefore combines criteria, the standards used to judge something; evidence, the observable details that support the judgment; and evaluation, the conclusion about the subject’s quality or effectiveness.
Reviews vary according to their subject, writer, and medium. A newspaper review, a scholarly review, a consumer review, and a video review may use different tones and structures, but they commonly present a focused subject, establish criteria, provide objective evidence, and reach an evaluation. The reviewer’s credibility matters throughout: readers must trust that the reviewer understands what is being judged and is applying standards fairly.
Establishing Criteria
A criterion is a standard used to evaluate something. Criteria answer the question, What makes this subject successful or unsuccessful? The criteria for a novel might include characterization, plot development, language, structure, originality, or the work’s relationship to a literary tradition. The criteria for a restaurant might include flavor, presentation, service, atmosphere, and price. The criteria must fit the subject; a reviewer should not judge a poem by exactly the same standards used to judge a washing machine.
A review’s subject is usually focused: it identifies one specific item, work, performance, service, or idea rather than making a vague statement about an entire category. A focused subject gives the writer something manageable to examine closely. “Modern fiction” is too broad for an ordinary review, while “the use of fragmented narration in one contemporary novel” gives the review a clear center.
The writer chooses criteria before, or while, forming the evaluation. These standards shape what the reviewer notices and prevent the review from becoming a list of disconnected reactions. A reviewer may value a film’s historical accuracy, for example, while another reviewer may emphasize emotional impact or technical innovation. Different criteria can produce different evaluations without automatically making one review dishonest. The important requirement is that the criteria be appropriate, understandable, and applied consistently.
A reviewer’s credibility depends partly on literary knowledge, meaning knowledge of literary history, forms, genres, conventions, and relationships among works. Literary knowledge allows a reviewer to explain not merely that a novel is “unusual,” but how it departs from or develops an established form. For example, a reviewer who knows the conventions of the historical novel can distinguish between an intentional reshaping of historical fiction and a simple factual mistake. That knowledge gives readers a reason to take the reviewer’s criteria and conclusions seriously.
Michiko Kakutani’s credibility as a reviewer is associated with historical knowledge and genre expertise that provide the backbone of her reviews. A reviewer demonstrates expertise by placing a work in context, recognizing its formal choices, and explaining how it compares with related works. Expertise does not mean that the reviewer’s opinion is automatically correct; it means that the opinion rests on informed standards rather than on an unexamined personal preference.
Example passage:
The novel’s alternating narrators are not simply a stylistic experiment. They recall the divided perspectives common in modernist fiction, but the shifts also reveal how each character misunderstands the same family history.
This passage establishes literary criteria involving narrative form, historical context, and characterization. It also demonstrates literary knowledge: the reviewer identifies a convention associated with modernist fiction and explains what the novel does with it. Rather than saying that the technique is “confusing” or “interesting,” the reviewer gives readers a standard for judging it and begins to show why the technique matters.
Providing Objective Evidence
Objective evidence is specific, observable information that supports a review’s claims. In a review, evidence may include details from the work itself, descriptions of a performance, facts about a product, or carefully reported observations about a service. Evidence makes evaluation more than personal taste. The reviewer may still reach a personal judgment, but the judgment should be supported by details that readers can examine.
Objectivity does not require the writer to have no opinion. A review is evaluative by nature, so the writer must make judgments. Objectivity means presenting those judgments fairly: describing the subject accurately, acknowledging relevant strengths and weaknesses, avoiding exaggeration, and connecting conclusions to evidence. A reviewer who dislikes a novel should not misrepresent its plot or ignore features that support a different response.
The writer’s choices of detail are therefore important. General claims such as “the acting is excellent,” “the argument is weak,” or “the book is boring” do not give readers enough information. The reviewer should identify the moment, feature, pattern, or comparison that supports the claim. Evidence should also be relevant to the criterion. A long description of a film’s costumes may not support a claim about the quality of its dialogue unless the reviewer explains the connection.
Evidence can establish credibility as well as support evaluation. A reviewer who accurately describes a work’s genre, structure, historical setting, or technical features shows that the work has been examined carefully. Kakutani’s historical knowledge and genre expertise function in this way: contextual knowledge helps her explain what a work is attempting and provides a basis for assessing whether it succeeds.
Example passage:
The restaurant’s menu promises regional cooking, but the signature stew is dominated by cream and dried herbs rather than the advertised peppers and citrus. The bread, however, is freshly baked, and the server explains each ingredient without prompting.
The passage uses objective evidence instead of relying on the unsupported statement that the restaurant is “bad.” It gives sensory details, compares the dish with the restaurant’s stated purpose, and records a service interaction. The evidence supports a qualified evaluation: the stew does not fulfill one criterion, while the bread and service fulfill others. This balance helps the reviewer avoid appearing biased.
A fair review may recognize that readers have different preferences. A reviewer can explain that a slow, experimental film may appeal to viewers who value atmosphere and symbolism even if it frustrates viewers who expect rapid action. Such acknowledgment does not weaken the evaluation. It clarifies the criteria and shows that the reviewer understands the difference between a work’s qualities and the reviewer’s personal response to those qualities.
Modes of Reviews
Reviews can appear in different modes, or forms shaped by purpose, audience, medium, and subject. The same work may receive a short consumer review, a newspaper or magazine review, a scholarly review, or an informal online review. These forms differ in length, depth, tone, evidence, and assumed audience. A brief review may offer a concise recommendation, while a longer review may explain a work’s genre, historical context, structure, and significance in detail.
The medium influences what a review can do. Print and online reviews can develop extended descriptions and comparisons. Broadcast or video reviews may rely more heavily on voice, visual demonstration, or performance. A review of a book can quote and analyze language directly; a review of a concert may describe sound, timing, staging, and the audience’s experience; a review of a product may emphasize function, durability, design, and value. In every mode, the reviewer still needs an identifiable subject, appropriate criteria, evidence, and an evaluation.
Reviews also differ in how strongly they emphasize description, analysis, and judgment. A descriptive review gives readers a clear sense of the subject. An analytical review examines how the subject works, often by considering form, structure, technique, or context. An evaluative review uses evidence and criteria to decide how well the subject succeeds. Most substantial reviews combine these modes rather than using only one: description identifies what is being judged, analysis explains how it operates, and evaluation states its value or limitations.
Example passage:
The concert begins with a nearly silent stage and a single violin line. As percussion gradually enters, the ensemble repeats the melody with increasing speed, turning a restrained opening into a tense finale. The arrangement is most effective when its repetition creates anticipation, although the final crescendo continues long after that tension has peaked.
The first sentence is primarily descriptive: it gives readers an experience of the performance. The second is analytical: it explains how repetition and changing instrumentation shape the music. The final sentence is evaluative: it identifies a success and a limitation according to a criterion of musical tension. Because the judgment grows from described and analyzed features, it is more persuasive than a simple recommendation.
Whatever its mode, a review should make its reasoning visible. Readers can test a reviewer’s credibility by asking four questions: Does the reviewer understand the subject and its genre? Are the criteria appropriate and clear? Does the evidence accurately support the claims? Does the final evaluation acknowledge complexity rather than merely announce a preference? A review is strongest when its knowledge, standards, observations, and judgment work together.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.
Source Materials
Study English Composition I on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages