From the free course English Composition I on Lykke

8.6 Editing Focus: Commas with Nonessential and Essential Information

Key concepts: Distinguishing essential information from nonessential information · Using commas with nonessential information · Deciding whether a relative clause is essential or nonessential · Relative clauses introduced by “whose” · Identifying the curriculum expert and the information that describes the expert

By the end of this section the student can: Distinguish between essential and nonessential information in sentences.; Use commas for clearer, more effective sentences.

8.6 Editing Focus: Commas with Nonessential and Essential Information

In the sentence “The department has consulted the curriculum expert whose textbook is widely used,” the words whose textbook is widely used may either identify the expert or simply add information about an expert already identified. That distinction determines whether commas belong in the sentence.

Nonessential and Essential Information

Essential information is information a reader needs in order to know exactly which person, place, thing, or idea the sentence means. Nonessential information adds detail about something already clear. The difference is not simply the length of the phrase or the presence of a relative word such as whose, that, or which. The difference depends on the role the information plays in the sentence’s meaning.

Essential information identifies; nonessential information describes.

Imagine that someone says, “Please bring me the folder.” If several folders are nearby, you may ask, “Which folder?” The answer “the folder with the blue label” supplies essential information because it identifies the correct folder. But if only one folder is present, “the folder, which has a blue label” adds a detail that the listener does not need in order to know which folder you mean. The same grammatical difference operates in academic sentences.

The surrounding context can change the punctuation. Consider the situation in which teachers are concerned that students are not retaining what they have learned. The department has consulted curriculum expert Malcolm Green. Because the expert’s name already identifies him, the information about his textbook can be treated as an additional description:

The department has consulted the curriculum expert Malcolm Green, whose textbook is widely used.

Here, Malcolm Green identifies the curriculum expert, while whose textbook is widely used supplies an extra fact about him. Removing the added clause leaves the sentence grammatically complete and still clear about which expert the department consulted: “The department has consulted the curriculum expert Malcolm Green.”

However, if the writer has not yet identified the expert by name, the same words can be essential:

The department has consulted the curriculum expert whose textbook is widely used.

In this version, the clause whose textbook is widely used helps the reader determine which curriculum expert the sentence means. It is not merely an interesting detail. It narrows the possible experts. Because it performs that identifying work, it is essential.

Nonessential Information

Nonessential information is set off from the rest of the sentence with commas. If the added information appears in the middle of a sentence, place one comma before it and one comma after it. If it appears at the end, place a comma before it.

Compare these patterns:

  • Middle position: “Malcolm Green, whose textbook is widely used, advised the department.”
  • End position: “The department consulted Malcolm Green, whose textbook is widely used.”

The commas act like verbal parentheses. They tell the reader, “This information is useful, but the sentence’s basic identification is already complete.” The clause whose textbook is widely used can be removed without destroying the central meaning:

The department consulted Malcolm Green.

The remaining sentence still names the person consulted. The clause contributes background information, not identification.

Do Not Place Commas around Essential Information

Essential information is not separated from the rest of the sentence by commas. Adding commas would incorrectly suggest that the information is optional.

The department consulted the curriculum expert whose textbook is widely used.

The clause directly follows the curriculum expert because it specifies which expert the department consulted. Writing “the curriculum expert, whose textbook is widely used” would signal that the department had already identified the expert and was merely adding a comment. That may be correct in a different context, but it changes the sentence’s meaning.

A useful editing test is to remove the underlined or highlighted material and ask two questions:

  1. After removal, does the reader still know exactly which person or thing the sentence refers to?
  2. Does the removed material merely provide an additional description?

If the reader still knows the identity, the information is probably nonessential and should be enclosed by commas. If removing it makes the reference vague or changes which person or thing is meant, the information is essential and should not be surrounded by commas.

Deciding Whether a Relative Clause Is Essential or Nonessential

A relative clause is a group of words that describes a noun and commonly begins with who, whose, that, or which. In the practice sentence, the relative clause is whose textbook is widely used. Its punctuation depends on whether it identifies the curriculum expert or merely comments on an already identified expert.

The most reliable method is to read the sentence as part of a real situation rather than applying a mechanical rule. Ask what the reader already knows. If the sentence has already named Malcolm Green, the clause is nonessential:

If no name or other identifying detail appears, the clause may be essential:

The clause therefore cannot be classified by whose alone. Whose introduces the relationship between the expert and the textbook; it does not automatically tell you whether commas are required. Meaning and context decide.

Relative Clauses Introduced by “Whose”

Whose shows possession or association. In the curriculum expert whose textbook is widely used, the textbook belongs to, or is associated with, the expert. The clause answers a possible identifying question: “Which curriculum expert?”

When the answer is needed to identify the noun, do not use commas:

When the noun has already been identified, use commas:

The department consulted Malcolm Green, whose textbook is widely used.

This distinction matters especially in analytical and professional writing. A comma can change whether readers understand a detail as part of the identifying evidence or as background information. Since an analytical report depends on precise relationships among facts, punctuation helps readers understand not only what information is present but also how important that information is to the reference.

Identifying the Curriculum Expert and the Information That Describes the Expert

In the sentence connected to the teachers’ concern about students’ retention, identify the sentence parts before deciding on commas:

  • Person or noun being described: the curriculum expert Malcolm Green
  • Descriptive relative clause: whose textbook is widely used
  • Central action: the department has consulted
  • Context: teachers are concerned that students are not retaining what they have learned

Because Malcolm Green identifies the expert, the clause about the textbook is additional information. The edited sentence is:

The writer could also make the name itself the direct noun being described:

The department has consulted Malcolm Green, whose textbook is widely used.

In both versions, the comma tells readers that the textbook detail describes Malcolm Green but does not distinguish him from other possible experts.

Practice Using Commas

For each sentence, first locate the noun being described. Then decide whether the highlighted information identifies that noun or adds a detail about a noun already identified.

1. The department has consulted the curriculum expert whose textbook is widely used.

Without additional context, whose textbook is widely used can be essential because it identifies which curriculum expert the department consulted. No commas are used. If the sentence had already named Malcolm Green, the punctuation would change: “The department has consulted the curriculum expert Malcolm Green, whose textbook is widely used.”

2. Two members of the math department Janelle Brady and Tye Lavalle are retiring next year.

The names identify which two members are retiring, so they are essential in this reading. No commas separate them from two members of the math department. The sentence states that the retiring members are Janelle Brady and Tye Lavalle.

3. The textbooks that are now in use are outdated.

The clause that are now in use identifies which textbooks are outdated. It is essential, so commas are not used.

4. Students have given feedback on the online classes that have replaced in-person classes.

The clause that have replaced in-person classes identifies the online classes under discussion. In this reading, it is essential and is not set off with commas.

5. The math department now offers more evening classes which attract more students and fewer summer classes.

The clause which attract more students adds information about the evening classes and contrasts with the fewer summer classes. Read as an added comment, it takes a comma: “The math department now offers more evening classes, which attract more students, and fewer summer classes.” The commas make clear that the evening classes have already been identified and that their ability to attract more students is additional information.

6. Several instructors who teach math also teach computer science classes.

The clause who teach math identifies which instructors also teach computer science. It is essential, so no commas are used. The sentence does not claim that all instructors teach math; it refers specifically to the instructors who do.

The central editing decision is therefore semantic, or meaning-based: determine whether the added words are necessary for identification. Once that decision is made, the comma rule is straightforward. Nonessential information receives commas; essential information remains attached to the noun it identifies.

Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.

8.6 Editing Focus: Commas with Nonessential and Essential Information - English Composition I - image 1
8.6 Editing Focus: Commas with Nonessential and Essential Information - English Composition I - image 1

Source Materials

Study English Composition I on Lykke

This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.

Add the free extensionSign in to open every section

All sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages

8.6 Editing Focus: Commas with Nonessential and Essential Information — English Composition I | Lykke