From the free course English Composition I on Lykke
2.1 Seeds of Self
Key concepts: W.E.B. Du Bois · Activism · Writing as a means of exploring identity and culture · Personal culture · Unconscious bias · Self-examination · Reflection · Culture as an aspect of identity · Bias as an aspect of identity
By the end of this section the student can: Explain the importance of communication in various cultural, language-related, and rhetorical situations.; Articulate how language use can promote social justice and equality.
2.1 Seeds of Self
Every act of communication reveals something about the speaker’s culture, position, and assumptions—even when the speaker intends to sound neutral. A greeting, an argument, a personal story, or a public protest carries expectations about who may speak, which language is considered legitimate, and what an audience is expected to value. Writing can make those hidden expectations visible. It can also challenge them.
The “seeds” of self are the experiences, languages, communities, histories, and beliefs from which a person’s identity grows. They are not a complete destiny. Writers can examine how those influences shape their perceptions and can use language to question unfair systems, represent overlooked experiences, and promote social justice and equality.
Understanding Culture
Culture is the shared system of values, practices, stories, assumptions, and ways of communicating that helps a group make meaning. Culture can be connected to nationality, ethnicity, religion, region, race, class, profession, family, generation, disability, or many other forms of community. A person usually participates in several cultures at once, and those cultures may sometimes support one another or pull in different directions.
Culture becomes especially visible when communication crosses a boundary. Between 1870 and 1900, nearly 12 million immigrants arrived in the United States, many through Ellis Island. Their experiences demonstrate that language is not merely a neutral tool for delivering information. Accents, names, unfamiliar idioms, literacy practices, and expectations about authority could affect how immigrants were understood and how they understood the institutions receiving them. A communication problem may therefore reflect unequal power, not simply an individual’s failure to speak clearly.
A cultural situation is an interaction shaped by the cultural identities and expectations of its participants. A rhetorical situation is the combination of a purpose, audience, context, and occasion that shapes what a writer says and how the writer says it. Effective communication requires more than correct grammar: a writer must consider what an audience knows, values, fears, or may misunderstand. The same claim may need different examples, explanations, levels of formality, or language choices in different situations.
A common misconception is that culture belongs only to people who have visibly different customs or who speak a language other than standard American English. The section’s emphasis on examining one’s own culture corrects that assumption. Familiar practices can feel natural rather than cultural precisely because they are familiar. The way a family handles disagreement, the language used for elders, the expectation that students should speak directly to teachers, or the belief that “professional” writing must sound impersonal are all learned practices.
Consider this short passage:
When my grandmother says, “You have eaten?” she is not checking a fact. She is asking whether I am cared for. I used to translate her question into standard English and lose its warmth; now I hear it as an invitation.
The writer makes a deliberate choice to explain a culturally specific expression rather than present it as strange or incorrect. The passage identifies a family practice, gives the writer’s earlier interpretation, and then revises that interpretation. That movement matters rhetorically: it invites readers into the experience without claiming that one form of communication is universally correct. The writer also shows how language carries relationships and values, not just dictionary meanings.
Understanding culture therefore requires attention to both difference and power. Writers should ask: Whose language is treated as standard? Which communication practices are labeled sophisticated, emotional, rude, or unprofessional? Who is expected to adapt? These questions prepare writers to recognize how language use can either preserve inequality or make room for fuller participation.
Situating Self
Situating self means locating one’s identity within the social, historical, and cultural conditions that shape perception. It does not mean reducing a person to a category. Instead, it asks writers to identify the experiences and positions from which they speak, including privileges they may possess and barriers they may have encountered.
Personal culture is part of this process. Personal culture is the particular combination of family histories, communities, languages, beliefs, experiences, and habits that an individual carries. Two people who share a national identity, racial identity, or language may still have very different personal cultures. A writer who situates the self avoids broad claims such as “my culture believes…” when the evidence really describes one family, neighborhood, or experience.
W.E.B. Du Bois offers a major example of writing as self-examination and public activism. In The Souls of Black Folk, he describes the experience of being Black in a society that imposes racist judgments while demanding that Black people see themselves through those judgments. He names this divided awareness double consciousness: the experience of seeing oneself both from one’s own perspective and through the eyes of a dominant society. Du Bois’s well-known phrase, “two souls, two thoughts,” captures this tension.
Du Bois did not treat identity as a private problem detached from public life. Through works such as The Philadelphia Negro and The Souls of Black Folk, he combined social investigation, history, autobiography, music, and argument to expose racial injustice. His writing examined how segregation, economic inequality, education, and public stereotypes shaped Black lives. His activism included organizing against racial violence and inequality and helping establish the NAACP, where writing and journalism became tools for public pressure. His example shows that exploring identity can also challenge the structures that attempt to define people from the outside.
Unconscious bias is an automatic association or assumption that influences judgment without deliberate awareness. It can affect communication when a reader treats one accent as intelligent and another as careless, assumes that a quiet person lacks authority, interprets directness differently depending on the speaker’s race or gender, or treats one dialect as “correct” while dismissing another as deficient. Unconscious bias does not require conscious hatred to produce unequal results.
Self-examination is the practice of looking critically at one’s own reactions, assumptions, and position. It is not a demand for perfect neutrality; no writer stands outside culture. Instead, it is a method for becoming more responsible. A writer can examine whose voices seem credible, which examples feel “normal,” what emotional responses arise toward a speaker, and whether a supposedly neutral standard advantages one group over another.
For example:
I called Marcus’s presentation “aggressive” because he interrupted twice. Later, I noticed that I had praised the same behavior in a confident speaker I already considered authoritative. My response was not a neutral description; it was an assumption about who was allowed to take up space.
This passage situates the writer by naming a judgment, revisiting it, and comparing two similar behaviors. The writer does not excuse interruption or claim that every interpretation is equally valid. Instead, the writer investigates how an unconscious bias may have shaped the description. That reflective move improves communication because it separates observable details from interpretations. “He interrupted twice” describes an action; “he was aggressive” adds a judgment that requires examination.
Situating self also changes how writers use evidence. A writer should distinguish personal experience from universal conclusions, acknowledge limits of knowledge, and represent other people’s identities with care. Such choices make an argument more accurate and ethically credible. They also help writers see that language can either reinforce stereotypes or make unjust assumptions easier to challenge.
Exploring Voice
Voice is the recognizable presence a writer creates through language, including word choice, rhythm, perspective, tone, detail, and stance. Voice is not simply a personality poured onto the page. It is shaped by rhetorical choices made for particular audiences and purposes. A writer may sound intimate in a memoir, measured in an analytical argument, urgent in an activist statement, or welcoming in a public explanation.
Exploring voice means asking which parts of one’s experience and language have been encouraged, silenced, translated, corrected, or treated as authoritative. Writers may draw on family expressions, community knowledge, multilingual experience, oral storytelling, humor, or forms of emphasis that conventional academic writing has sometimes excluded. The goal is not to reject clarity or audience awareness. The goal is to understand that “clear” and “proper” are often cultural judgments, and to choose deliberately rather than automatically.
Du Bois’s writing demonstrates how voice can combine personal experience with public argument. He uses autobiography to establish the reality of lived experience, historical discussion to explain its causes, sociological observation to document conditions, and lyrical language to communicate emotional and cultural meaning. This mixture refuses the idea that only one voice—detached, impersonal, and supposedly universal—can produce serious knowledge. His writing makes identity part of the evidence while connecting individual experience to collective injustice.
A writer exploring voice might write:
At home, silence is not emptiness. It is the pause before an elder decides whether a question deserves an answer. At school, that pause follows me into discussions, where it is mistaken for uncertainty. I am learning to enter the conversation without abandoning the patience I was taught.
The passage uses short sentences, repetition of “pause,” and a contrast between home and school. Those choices let the writer preserve a cultural meaning rather than translate it into a deficit such as “I am shy” or “I do not participate.” The final sentence creates agency: the writer is not choosing between cultural identity and academic participation but finding a way to bring both into the conversation.
Voice also has an ethical dimension. Writers who communicate across cultural or language-related differences should avoid treating their own perspective as the default. They can explain unfamiliar terms, preserve meaningful differences, identify whose experiences are missing, and revise language that stereotypes or excludes. At the same time, writers should not assume that one person can speak for an entire culture. A precise voice acknowledges the limits of personal experience while still claiming the authority to describe what one has genuinely lived and observed.
The central connection among culture, self, and voice is communication as a form of responsibility. Understanding culture helps a writer recognize that language carries values. Situating self reveals how identity and unconscious bias shape interpretation. Exploring voice enables the writer to make purposeful choices about representation and audience. Together, these practices allow writing to do more than express an individual viewpoint: writing can expose injustice, widen whose experiences count, and promote social justice and equality.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.
Source Materials
Study English Composition I on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition I · Browse more course pages