From the free course English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based on Lykke
9.5 Writing Process: Thinking Critically about Rhetoric
Key concepts: Rhetoric · Rhetorical analysis · Author’s purpose and rhetorical strategies · Audience and writer-reader interaction · Credibility and ethos · Emotional appeals · Slippery-slope reasoning · Rhetorical devices and language use · Thesis statements · Multimodal rhetorical analysis
By the end of this section the student can: Develop a rhetorical analysis through multiple drafts.; Identify and analyze rhetorical strategies in a rhetorical analysis.; Demonstrate flexible strategies for generating ideas, drafting, reviewing, collaborating, revising, rewriting, and editing.; Give and act on productive feedback for works in progress.
9.5 Writing Process: Thinking Critically about Rhetoric
Rhetoric is the deliberate use of language, organization, and evidence to influence an audience. A rhetorical analysis asks not simply whether a writer is right, but how the writing works: what the author wants readers to believe or do, which strategies create that effect, and how successfully those strategies respond to a particular audience.
A useful everyday example is a request to change a household rule. “Please let me study in the living room tonight because the room is quieter” uses a reason. “You know how stressful exams are” appeals to emotion. “I have finished my chores and will leave by ten” builds credibility. The request becomes persuasive through the interaction of these choices with the listener’s expectations. Rhetorical analysis examines that interaction in a written text.
The central misconception is that rhetorical analysis means praising or criticizing an author according to whether the reader agrees. Instead, analysis requires enough detachment to identify the writer’s tools and explain what those tools accomplish. A writer may conclude that an argument is effective, ineffective, or effective for some readers but not others. Agreement is not the standard; rhetorical effectiveness is.
Summary of Assignment: Rhetorical Analysis
A rhetorical analysis is an examination of the choices a writer makes to persuade an audience. The assignment asks you to identify rhetorical strategies, explain how the strategies function, and evaluate their effectiveness. It is therefore different from a summary, which reports what a text says, and different from a personal response, which emphasizes what you think or feel about the subject.
The analysis begins with the author’s purpose, or intended result. An author may want readers to accept a claim, reconsider an assumption, take an action, or feel urgency about an issue. The analysis also considers the audience: readers do not approach a text neutrally. They may already agree, disagree, feel hostile, know the subject well, or encounter the ideas as unfamiliar or radical. These conditions affect which strategies the author chooses and how readers are likely to interpret them.
The writer-reader relationship is part of the rhetoric. A writer may present themself as a trusted participant in a field or as an outsider who must first earn the audience’s confidence. Ethos, or credibility, develops through signals such as relevant knowledge, fair treatment of opposing views, appropriate tone, and evidence of good judgment. Pathos, or emotional appeal, attempts to shape the audience’s feelings; common emotional appeals include fear, guilt, anger, love, loyalty, patriotism, and duty. Logical reasoning and evidence can also support persuasion, but no strategy works independently of audience and context.
For example, consider this short passage:
“The city should lower the speed limit near schools. Last month, a child was struck two blocks from Lincoln Elementary, and slower traffic would give drivers more time to stop.”
The author’s purpose is to persuade readers to support a policy change. The specific accident creates pathos by making the danger concrete, while the explanation about stopping time supplies a logical reason. The reference to a particular school and recent event may make the issue immediate for local readers. An analysis would not merely say that the passage is persuasive; it would explain how urgency, local knowledge, emotional consequence, and practical reasoning work together. It might also ask whether readers who distrust speed restrictions would find the evidence sufficient.
The assignment’s standard is evaluation through explanation. A strong analysis identifies a choice, connects that choice to the author’s purpose and audience, and judges its effect. The basic movement is:
- Identify the rhetorical strategy.
- Explain what the strategy does in the passage.
- Connect its effect to the intended audience.
- Evaluate whether it advances the author’s purpose.
Quick Launch: Start with a Thesis Statement
Beginning with a thesis statement gives the analysis direction before drafting becomes overwhelming. A thesis statement is the controlling claim of an essay: it states what the writer argues about the text’s rhetorical choices and their effects. For rhetorical analysis, the thesis should move beyond “the author uses rhetoric effectively.” It should identify significant strategies and explain why they matter.
A useful thesis often names the author’s purpose, the audience or situation, the major strategies, and the resulting effect. It does not need to list every observation. Instead, it gives the draft a selective argument. For example: “By combining a local accident anecdote with practical reasoning about stopping distance, the writer makes a speed-limit proposal urgent and reasonable for concerned community members, although readers skeptical of regulation may still want stronger statistical evidence.”
This thesis makes several choices. It identifies two strategies rather than vaguely calling the article “persuasive.” It explains the intended audience’s likely response. It also includes a qualification: the argument may work better for concerned residents than for readers who distrust regulation. That qualification makes the claim analytical rather than absolute.
A weak opening would say, “This article is about school safety, and the author uses ethos, pathos, and logos.” That sentence announces topics but does not make an arguable claim about effect. A stronger launch asks: What does the author want? Which choices seem designed to achieve it? What might help or hinder that effort? Those questions turn observations into a thesis.
A short example shows the difference:
“Our neighborhood deserves safer crossings. As a crossing guard for twelve years, I have watched drivers rush through the intersection, and the city’s own report records twenty-three near-misses this year.”
A thesis based on this passage could argue that the writer combines ethos from professional experience with official evidence to make a neighborhood complaint appear both personally witnessed and objectively documented. The thesis does not simply label the appeals; it predicts their rhetorical effect on readers who might otherwise dismiss the complaint as anecdotal.
Drafting: Text Evidence and Analysis of Effect
As drafting begins, the analysis should use specific text evidence, meaning brief words or passages that demonstrate the claim. Evidence is not a substitute for explanation. A quotation shows what the author wrote; analysis explains why that wording, arrangement, image, example, or appeal matters.
A dependable paragraph pattern is claim, evidence, analysis, and connection. First, state the rhetorical choice you are examining. Next, quote or describe a precise passage. Then analyze the effect of the choice on the intended audience. Finally, connect that effect to the author’s larger purpose and to the thesis. The most important part is usually the analysis after the quotation.
For example:
“The bridge is not a shortcut; it is a promise that every child can reach school safely.”
The metaphor changes a transportation structure into a moral commitment. “Shortcut” suggests convenience, while “promise” suggests responsibility and trust. The reference to children intensifies the emotional stakes and may encourage parents to view bridge funding as an obligation rather than an optional expense. The passage therefore supports a purpose of building public support, though an analysis could also note that emotional language does not by itself prove that the bridge is financially feasible.
Writers should avoid dropping quotations into a paragraph without interpretation. “The bridge is a promise” is not analysis by itself. Analysis begins when the writer explains the metaphor’s connotations, identifies the audience it addresses, and evaluates whether the emotional appeal strengthens or oversimplifies the proposal. The same strategy can produce different effects for different readers: parents may find the language compelling, while budget-conscious readers may regard it as manipulative unless paired with cost evidence.
Drafting also requires attention to rhetorical devices and language use. Figurative language, including similes and metaphors, can make an abstract position vivid. Organization can establish priority by placing a personal story before statistics or a call to action after evidence. Word choice can create urgency, sympathy, authority, or suspicion. The analysis should identify these choices only when they contribute to the argument; listing devices without explaining their effects produces description rather than rhetorical analysis.
Peer Review: Guidelines toward Revision and the “Golden Rule”
Peer review treats writing as work in progress rather than as a finished performance. The reviewer’s task is to help the writer see how the draft may be received by an actual reader. Productive feedback asks whether the thesis is clear, whether the evidence supports the claims, whether the analysis explains effects, and whether the discussion consistently considers purpose and audience.
The “golden rule” of peer review is to treat another writer’s draft as you would want your own draft treated: with attention, respect, honesty, and usefulness. Respect does not mean withholding criticism. It means directing comments toward the writing and its possible revision rather than judging the writer. “This paragraph does not explain how the quotation affects skeptical readers” is more useful than “This paragraph is bad.”
A careful reviewer can distinguish global concerns from local concerns. Global concerns include an unclear thesis, missing rhetorical strategies, weak organization, or insufficient connection to audience. Local concerns include awkward wording, punctuation, or sentence-level repetition. Higher-level issues generally deserve attention first because polishing sentences cannot repair an analysis whose central claim is unclear.
For example, a peer might read this sentence:
“The author uses fear, and this is effective.”
A golden-rule response would identify the opportunity rather than merely mark the sentence wrong: “Can you quote the language that creates fear and explain which readers would respond to it? You might also consider whether the fear encourages action or makes the author seem alarmist.” This feedback gives the writer specific questions that can lead to revision.
Peer review is collaborative, not an invitation to rewrite someone else’s essay according to personal preference. A reviewer should explain the reader’s experience, identify strengths worth preserving, and offer focused suggestions. The writer remains responsible for deciding which feedback fits the purpose and argument of the draft.
Revising: Staying Open to Feedback and Working with It
Revision means re-seeing and reshaping the argument, not merely correcting grammar. After receiving feedback, the writer considers what readers understood, where they became uncertain, and which claims need stronger evidence or explanation. Staying open to feedback does not require accepting every suggestion. It requires examining each suggestion seriously and deciding whether it reveals a genuine problem for the intended audience.
Revision may lead to a new thesis, a different order of paragraphs, more precise quotations, fuller discussion of ethos or emotional appeals, or a qualification about competing audiences. A writer may discover that a passage initially labeled “logos” actually depends more heavily on credibility, or that a powerful emotional example needs factual support. Such discoveries are signs of analysis developing, not evidence that the first draft failed.
Suppose a reviewer says that an analysis describes an author’s emotional language but never explains its effect. The writer could revise:
Before: “The author uses fear by describing children near traffic.”
After: “By placing children in the path of speeding traffic, the author turns an abstract safety debate into an immediate threat, encouraging parents to support restrictions; however, readers who expect statistical evidence may find the appeal incomplete.”
The revision adds mechanism, audience, and evaluation. It explains how the image works, identifies the readers most likely to respond, and acknowledges a limitation. This is the central habit of rhetorical analysis: move from naming a strategy to explaining its consequences.
A complete process includes generating ideas, drafting, reviewing, collaborating, revising, rewriting, and editing. Each stage asks a different question. Generation finds possible strategies and effects. Drafting gives those ideas a provisional shape. Peer review tests the draft through another reader’s experience. Revising changes the argument or structure. Rewriting clarifies passages that need substantial reconstruction. Editing improves correctness after the reasoning and organization are sound. The result should be an analysis that identifies rhetorical choices, explains their effects, and evaluates how well they serve the author’s purpose for a particular audience.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.



Source Materials
Study English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based · Browse more course pages