From the free course English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based on Lykke
12.2 Trailblazer
Key concepts: Argumentative research · Samin Nosrat as a research trailblazer · Emotional concerns in argument · Rallying readers toward a position · Use of evidence and quotations · Thesis statement support · Transitions and paragraph/section coherence · Consistency of voice and precision · Primary and secondary sources · Visual protest rhetoric about the Iraq War
By the end of this section the student can: Identify and explain key rhetorical concepts.; Analyze how authors make claims and support them with evidence in a range of activities outside of academic writing.
12.2 Trailblazer
A recipe can be an argument: it tells readers what to do, promises a result, and offers reasons to trust the method. Samin Nosrat’s work makes this especially visible because cooking instructions depend on claims about how ingredients behave and how particular choices produce particular outcomes. Her example shows that argumentative research is not limited to formal academic essays. Whenever writers make claims, support them, and guide readers toward a choice, they are working rhetorically.
Argumentative Research Trailblazer: Samin Nosrat
Argumentative research uses researched information to make and support a position on an issue. The writer does more than collect facts. The writer selects evidence for a purpose, interprets that evidence for a particular audience, and organizes it so that readers can understand why a claim deserves acceptance.
Samin Nosrat serves as a trailblazer because her work demonstrates how research-based argument can operate outside the conventional academic paper. A cookbook author may appear to be giving instructions rather than arguing, but every instruction rests on an implied claim: a certain method, ingredient, sequence, or proportion will lead to a desirable result. The writer therefore has to establish credibility, explain relationships between choices and outcomes, and anticipate what readers need to know.
The brief statement “I love doing the homework on recipes” captures an important distinction. Research is not merely a preliminary chore completed before the “real” writing begins. For Nosrat, investigation becomes part of the work itself. Research helps her understand the subject, test or clarify claims, and translate specialized knowledge into guidance that readers can use.
Her example also broadens the meaning of an argumentative writer. An argument does not have to sound combative, and it does not always announce an explicit disagreement. A writer can argue by recommending a practice, explaining why one approach works better than another, or asking readers to reconsider an assumption. The central test is whether the writing advances a position and gives readers reasons to accept it.
Emotional Concerns in Argument
Emotional concerns are the fears, desires, values, and sensory responses that influence how audiences receive an argument. They include reactions to what readers may fear or desire, appeals to the five senses, and broader sentiments such as love, loyalty, anger, justice, and patriotism. Emotional appeal is not automatically irrational. It becomes rhetorically effective when it connects the subject to consequences and values that matter to the audience.
A writer can appeal to emotional concerns by addressing an incident or outcome that readers fear or desire. If readers fear harm, loss, injustice, or failure, a writer may emphasize evidence showing that the danger is real or preventable. If readers desire safety, fairness, pleasure, belonging, or success, the writer may show how a proposed position can help produce that outcome. In both cases, emotion gives the issue human significance.
The Iraq War protest materials illustrate this strategy starkly. The large black banner presents the claims “IRAQ,” “2,000,000 DEAD,” “4,000,000 FLED,” and “GENOCIDE.” The sign uses numerical evidence, but the numbers do not function as emotionally neutral decoration. Death, displacement, and the accusation of genocide invite grief, anger, moral judgment, and urgency. The smaller poster showing a child with the words “Children of the Gulf War” intensifies the appeal by focusing attention on vulnerable human beings rather than on abstract policy alone.
The protestor’s argument therefore combines logos, or an appeal through information and reasoning, with pathos, or an appeal to emotion. The statistics give the claim apparent scale and specificity; the child-centered image gives that scale a human face. A common misconception is that emotional appeal weakens an argument because it replaces evidence. In a strong argument, emotional concerns and evidence work together: evidence establishes what happened, while emotional framing helps readers understand why it matters.
Rallying Readers Toward a Position
To rally readers is to move them toward a shared position or action. Rallying does not mean forcing agreement through exaggeration. It means presenting an issue in a way that makes a response seem necessary, reasonable, or morally important to the intended audience.
The protest sign rallies readers by compressing a complicated political argument into a few forceful elements. “IRAQ” identifies the subject. The death and refugee figures supply quantitative support. “GENOCIDE” supplies an interpretive claim about the meaning and seriousness of those events. The child image extends the argument beyond numbers to human consequence. Together, these choices tell viewers not only what the protestor believes but also how viewers should regard the issue.
A short public message must make selective choices because it cannot include every qualification, source, or historical detail. That limitation makes rhetorical judgment essential. The writer decides which facts deserve prominence, which emotional concerns will matter to the audience, and what action or judgment the message should encourage. A longer research argument has more space for context, but it faces the same basic task.
For example, a writer arguing that a community should preserve a public garden might write: “Because the garden provides the neighborhood’s only shaded gathering place and supports free food-growing workshops, the city should protect it from development.” The sentence appeals to practical community benefits and shared values while advancing a clear position. It does not merely say that the garden is pleasant; it gives readers reasons to support preservation.
Claims, Evidence, and Quotations
A claim is a statement that asks readers to accept an idea, interpretation, judgment, or recommendation. Claims should be supported with quoted or paraphrased evidence. Quoting reproduces a source’s exact words briefly; paraphrasing restates the source’s meaning in the writer’s own words. Both methods require the writer to represent the source accurately and explain its relevance.
Evidence is not persuasive simply because it exists. It must demonstrate the writer’s intent and consistently support the thesis statement. This means that a statistic, quotation, example, or observation should have a visible relationship to the point being made. Evidence that is interesting but unrelated can distract readers and weaken the argument.
Consider the difference between these two uses of evidence:
“The garden should be preserved because it matters to the community.”
This claim is broad but unsupported. A stronger version connects evidence directly to the position:
“A city survey found that residents use the garden for weekly food-growing workshops and outdoor gatherings, making its preservation a practical investment in neighborhood access to shared space.”
The second passage does more than add a fact. It explains what the fact proves. The survey supports the claim that the garden serves a community function, and the phrase “practical investment” interprets that function for readers who may be weighing costs or competing uses. Evidence becomes argumentative when the writer shows how it advances the thesis.
The Iraq War banner demonstrates another form of evidence: numerical data displayed for immediate public attention. Statistics can strengthen an argument by communicating scale, but numbers also require careful presentation. Readers may ask who collected them, what period they cover, and how the categories were defined. A responsible writer does not assume that a large number automatically proves every conclusion. The writer connects the data to a precise claim and supplies enough context for readers to understand its significance.
Working with Primary and Secondary Sources
The identity of a source depends partly on the question being asked. A text can be a secondary source about one subject and a primary source about another. The section makes this distinction through the example of a source that is secondary about an artist but primary about the scholar who wrote about that artist.
If a writer is studying the artist, the scholar’s discussion interprets or analyzes the artist’s work; it is therefore secondary evidence about the artist. If a writer is studying the scholar’s own ideas, language, or scholarly practice, that same discussion becomes a primary source about the scholar. “Primary” and “secondary” do not describe permanent labels attached to documents. They describe how a source functions in a particular investigation.
This distinction matters when building an argument because writers must explain what a source can legitimately establish. A scholar’s interpretation may support a claim about how an artwork has been understood, but it does not automatically function as firsthand evidence of the artist’s intentions. Careful argumentative research matches each source to the claim it can support.
Thesis Statement Support and Organization
A thesis statement is the central position that organizes an argument. Each major claim should contribute to that position, and each piece of evidence should help support one of those claims. The rubric emphasizes that an essay should focus on its thesis, support claims with quoted or paraphrased evidence, and maintain a consistent voice and awareness of the rhetorical situation.
A useful test is to ask of every paragraph: What does this paragraph help readers believe, and how does that belief support the thesis? If the answer is unclear, the writer may need to remove the material, supply a transition, or explain the evidence more fully.
Well-chosen transitions connect most paragraphs and sections. Transitions are words, phrases, or sentences that show relationships among ideas. “Similarly” signals comparison; “however” signals contrast; “as a result” signals consequence; and “more importantly” signals emphasis. Strong transitions do not merely make prose sound smoother. They reveal the argument’s logical movement.
For example: “The statistics establish the scale of displacement. More importantly, however, the image of the child shows why the protestor presents that displacement as a moral crisis.” The transition “more importantly, however” tells readers that the argument is shifting from quantity to interpretation. It helps the paragraph develop rather than simply adding another disconnected detail.
The strongest argumentative writing therefore coordinates several choices: it identifies a debatable position, selects evidence that genuinely supports it, explains the evidence, addresses what readers fear or desire, and guides readers through connected paragraphs. Samin Nosrat’s research-centered work and the Iraq War protest materials reveal the same principle in different settings: effective argument depends not only on having information, but on shaping information so an audience can recognize its importance and move toward a position.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.


Source Materials
Study English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based · Browse more course pages