From the free course English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based on Lykke
9.2 Trailblazer
Key concepts: Critical thinking about a text · Rhetorical strategies · Housing inequality · Residential segregation · The American dream of stable and affordable housing · Milwaukee’s racial housing divide · Broca’s theory · Leborgne’s limited ability to communicate · Gangrenous infection · Sepsis
By the end of this section the student can: Demonstrate the ability to think critically about a text.; Identify and analyze rhetorical strategies.
9.2 Trailblazer
A text persuades not only through what it says, but through the evidence it selects, the emotions it activates, and the assumptions it asks readers to accept. Critical thinking means examining those choices closely rather than treating a confident statement as a complete argument.
Learning Outcomes
By the end of this lesson, you should be able to demonstrate critical thinking about a text and identify and analyze rhetorical strategies. These abilities work together: critical thinking tests the strength and implications of an argument, while rhetorical analysis explains how the argument attempts to influence its audience.
A critical reader asks questions such as: What claim is being made? What evidence supports it? Which experiences or values does the writer emphasize? What information is missing? Who benefits from accepting the argument? These questions do not automatically reject a text. Instead, they distinguish between understanding an argument and evaluating it.
Rhetorical analysis adds another layer. It studies the relationship among a writer’s purpose, audience, evidence, language, and persuasive appeals. The goal is not merely to label a passage as using logos or pathos—the concepts introduced earlier—but to explain how those choices operate and whether they are effective in the situation.
Introduction: Living by Their Own Words
Story as Persuasion
Jamil Smith’s discussion of Milwaukee’s housing divide presents a social problem through both argument and human consequence. Milwaukee is described as one of the most racially divided cities in the nation. That description does more than provide background: it frames housing inequality as a structural condition rather than as a series of isolated personal misfortunes.
The central concern is the American dream of stable and affordable housing. In its familiar form, that dream suggests that ordinary people should be able to secure a safe, lasting home through work and responsible effort. Smith’s account challenges the assumption that this opportunity is equally available to everyone. The housing divide prevents poor people from achieving that dream and helps maintain a system of segregation that conflicts with the founding ideal of equality.
This is a significant rhetorical move. The argument does not describe housing merely as a market commodity or a private household concern. It connects housing to citizenship, fairness, opportunity, and national ideals. Because readers may already value equality and the American dream, the argument invites them to compare those ideals with the actual effects of residential segregation.
Residential Segregation and the Housing Divide
Residential segregation is the separation of groups into different neighborhoods or housing environments, often along racial and economic lines. In Smith’s discussion, segregation is not presented as a neutral pattern on a map. It is a system with consequences: where people live affects their access to stability, affordability, and the opportunities associated with secure housing.
The phrase “housing divide” emphasizes separation while also suggesting unequal power. A divide has two sides, but the sides do not necessarily possess equal resources or choices. Poor residents may face barriers that restrict where they can live, while wealthier residents have more ability to select neighborhoods and housing conditions. Critical reading therefore requires attention to the system producing the divide, not only to the visible fact that neighborhoods differ.
The argument also works through a contrast between legal or moral principle and lived deprivation. Housing can be discussed through laws, rights, and public policy, but deprivation is experienced by individuals. Smith’s rhetorical force comes from holding both levels together: readers are asked to see housing inequality as wrong in principle and damaging in people’s lives.
Logos and Pathos
Smith’s argument uses logos, an appeal based on reasoning and evidence, by encouraging readers to consider the legal aspects of housing. The question becomes not simply whether some neighborhoods are poor or segregated, but whether the arrangements governing housing are fair and consistent with equality. This appeal gives the discussion an analytical and civic dimension.
The argument also uses pathos, an appeal to emotion, by emphasizing the effects of deprivation on individuals. Readers are encouraged to imagine what it means to be denied stable and affordable housing. The emotional appeal does not replace reasoning; it gives the reasoning human significance. A legal argument may establish that a practice is unjust, while attention to personal suffering helps readers understand why the injustice matters.
A useful analysis therefore avoids the shallow conclusion that logos is “facts” and pathos is “feelings.” The important question is how the appeals cooperate. In Smith’s discussion, legal and social reasoning establishes the seriousness of the issue, while the human consequences make the issue difficult to dismiss as an abstract policy dispute.
A strong rhetorical analysis explains not only which appeal appears, but what the appeal makes the reader notice, value, or feel.
Evaluating an Enticing Argument
Smith’s argument is described as enticing in several ways because it connects recognizable ideals to evidence of unequal conditions. It gives readers a reason to care, a framework for judging the issue, and a moral contrast between equality as a founding ideal and segregation as a continuing reality.
Critical thinking, however, includes evaluating persuasive arguments that seem compelling. Critics point out that the proposed solution may fix symptoms rather than the deeper system producing the housing divide. This criticism does not necessarily disprove the argument’s description of the problem. Instead, it distinguishes between two questions: Is the diagnosis persuasive? and Will the proposed remedy address the causes?
That distinction is essential in argumentative reading. A writer may accurately show that people suffer, convincingly establish that a condition is unjust, and still offer a solution whose reach is limited. The critical reader tests the whole chain: claim, evidence, explanation, and remedy.
Trailblazer: Louis Victor “Tan” Leborgne
Patient History and Treatment
The case of Louis Victor “Tan” Leborgne demonstrates a different kind of rhetorical persuasion. Rather than arguing directly about public policy, the medical case constructs knowledge from an individual patient’s history, treatment, death, and autopsy. Its persuasive power depends heavily on precise observation and the authority of recorded evidence.
The clinical account records that the patient expired on 17 April 1861 at 11:00 a.m. The stated cause of death was gangrenous infection and sepsis. Such exact details establish a formal, documentary tone. The date and time make the report seem accountable and verifiable; the medical cause identifies the immediate physical explanation for death.
These details also show that evidence is shaped by genre. A medical case history does not usually persuade through vivid storytelling or moral appeal in the same way a social argument might. It persuades by organizing observations into a record that other investigators can examine. The writer’s restraint is itself rhetorical: precision signals seriousness and credibility.
Broca’s Broad Theory
Broca proposes a theory about Leborgne’s limited ability to communicate: “the condition must be related to brain function.” The statement moves from an individual observation to a broader explanatory claim. Leborgne’s communication difficulty becomes evidence in a larger investigation into the relationship between language and the brain.
This is a theory rather than a final conclusion. Broca’s claim is presented as something to be tested later in the case study. If correct, it might apply to how the brain works for everyone. The conditional structure matters: the argument reaches beyond the patient, but it acknowledges that the broader claim requires further evidence.
The reasoning can be represented in ordinary prose: Leborgne has a limited ability to communicate; his condition may be connected to brain function; examination of his brain may test that explanation. The movement is from observation, to hypothesis, to possible general application. Critical thinking asks whether each step is justified and whether the evidence supports extending an individual case to a general theory.
Autopsy Findings
The autopsy supplies the next major body of evidence. Broca reports performing it 24 hours after death and finding irregularities in the patient’s brain. A softened area over the perisylvian region contained a cavity about the size of a chicken’s egg, filled with serous fluid. The account also identifies volume loss affecting several brain structures, including the gyri, subcortical perisylvian area, insula, and part of the striate nucleus.
The specialized vocabulary and measured description serve a rhetorical purpose. They make the findings appear observable rather than speculative. The report does not simply say that the brain was “damaged”; it identifies location, physical condition, approximate size, contents, and affected regions. Specificity allows the reader to follow how the evidence might bear on Broca’s theory.
The case nevertheless requires careful interpretation. One patient can provide an important clue without proving a universal rule by itself. The rhetorical strength of the case comes from the connection between the patient’s communication difficulty and the physical findings, but the broader theory depends on testing and comparison beyond this single observation.
Critical Thinking Across the Two Readings
The Milwaukee discussion and the Leborgne case persuade in different genres, yet both reward the same disciplined habit: separate observation from interpretation. Milwaukee’s racial housing divide is an observed social condition interpreted as a failure of equality and opportunity. Leborgne’s communication difficulty and brain irregularities are observations interpreted as evidence for a theory about brain function.
The readings also show that rhetorical analysis is not limited to speeches or openly emotional writing. A policy argument may use legal reasoning and emotional consequences; a medical report may use chronology, technical precision, and cautious hypothesis. In each case, readers should ask how the form of presentation guides belief.
The most complete critical response combines explanation and evaluation: identify the claim, describe the rhetorical strategies, trace the evidence, and judge whether the conclusion reaches farther than the support allows. That process turns reading from passive acceptance into informed judgment.
Content adapted from OpenStax Writing Guide with Handbook by Michelle Bachelor Robinson, Maria Jerskey et al., licensed CC BY 4.0.
Source Materials
Study English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based on Lykke
This course page is free to open: signed out, you can read its first two sections, and signing in, on any plan, opens the rest. The free Lykke Chrome extension syncs your own Canvas courses, so ChatGPT, Claude and Muse can answer from your classes and deadlines. It only reads Canvas.
Add the free extensionSign in to open every sectionAll sections of English Composition II: Rhetorical Methods–Based · Browse more course pages